Asylums Are Not Answer To Failing Mental Health System

SANE Australia

SANE warns that calls to return to institutionalisation risk reinforcing stigma and distracting from the real issue: the urgent need to rebuild Australia's community mental health, supported housing and psychosocial recovery systems.

In response to the proposition by Melbourne's Lord Mayor Nicholas Reece that psychiatric asylums ought to be brought back, SANE said Australia should instead be focused on fixing the gaps that leave people with complex mental health needs without adequate treatment, housing and ongoing support.

SANE CEO Rachel Green said the community was right to expect better from the mental health system, but returning to institutionalisation was not the answer.

"We should absolutely be talking about the failures of Australia's mental health system. But people with mental health challenges don't need to be locked away. They need access to the treatment, housing and ongoing support that have too often been missing, including inpatient care when it is clinically needed.

"Instead of looking backwards to institutionalisation, we should be focused on building the services we know help people recover."

Ms Green said public conversations about mental health should focus on evidence-based solutions rather than reviving outdated models of care.

"What we don't hear nearly enough about is recovery. We don't hear about what happens when somebody has stable supported housing, effective treatment, psychosocial rehabilitation, peer support, support for families and carers, and people who stick with them for the long term."

Ms Green said there was a wide range of evidence-based support available between expecting someone to manage alone in the community and confining them in an institution.

"If we want Australians to support greater investment in mental health, we need to show what properly resourced care can achieve."

SANE said the challenges facing Australia's mental health system have already been recognised at a national level. The Productivity Commission's review of the National Mental Health and Suicide Prevention Agreement found services remain fragmented, difficult to navigate and out of reach for many Australians, while major gaps in psychosocial supports remain unresolved.

SANE Chief Clinical Officer Dr Rahul Khanna said the debate should focus on the gaps that exist across the mental health system.

"People with complex mental health conditions often require longer-term treatment and support than the system is currently able to provide. Without the right services in place, many end up caught in a revolving door of repeated crises and hospital admissions.

"The answer is not a return to institutionalisation. It's a better continuum of care."

Ms Green said Australia's history of psychiatric asylums should not be romanticised.

"We need to be clear about what asylums actually were. They were institutions built around segregation and detention, where people were separated from their communities and stripped of independence."

One-sided public commentary that reduces complex mental illness in a way that drives public fear and discrimination does nothing to motivate the public and political will required to properly resource the system.

"Serious incidents deserve serious scrutiny. We should ask what happened, what services were available, where the gaps were and what could prevent it happening again."

/Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).