Link to report summary
- NSW sentencing reforms: results from a survey of judicial officers
- The impact of the 2018 NSW sentencing reforms on supervised community orders and short-term prison
The 2018 sentencing reforms increased supervised community sentences and reduced both short-term prison sentences and unsupervised community sentences according to a report released today by the NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research (BOCSAR).
In September 2018 the NSW Government introduced reforms that made community sentencing options more flexible in order to maximise opportunities for offenders to be supervised and to engage in rehabilitative and therapeutic programs.
Two aims of the reforms were to:
- Increase the proportion of offenders sentenced to supervised community-based orders;
- Reduce the proportion of offenders serving short prison sentences;
BOCSAR found the reforms achieved both these objectives. The proportion of adult offenders in the Local Court who received a supervised community order increased significantly from 14.6% to 22.0% after the sentencing reforms commenced. The percentage of offenders who received a short-term prison sentence of 12 months or less significantly declined from 5.2% to 4.4%.
Similar results were found for Domestic Violence offenders and Aboriginal offenders in the Local Court and adult offenders in the District and Supreme Courts.
A second study undertaken by BOCSAR in partnership with the Judicial Commission of NSW assessed judicial confidence in the new sentencing reforms through a survey of 93 magistrates and judges.
Judicial officers generally agree that the reforms are operating as intended. 71% believe offenders have more opportunity to serve a supervised community-based order, 57% agree that new community-based options provide more flexibility in sentencing decisions and 47% agree that offenders have more opportunity to participate in rehabilitation programs.
However, a number of concerns were raised by judicial officers. Some were concerned about the Corrective Services practice of suspending supervision for low risk offenders regardless of the sentencing conditions stipulated by the judicial officer. Another concern was the lack of transparency regarding breaches of Intensive Corrections Orders (a community based alternative to full-time custody) which are overseen by the State Parole Authority.
Commenting on the findings, BOCSAR Executive Director, Jackie Fitzgerald said it is clear that the sentencing reforms have had the desired impact of increasing the opportunities for offenders to receive the potentially therapeutic benefits of supervision. "The ultimate goal of the reform, however, is to reduce reoffending. We won't have an answer as to whether the reforms have achieved this aim until 2021."
