Unlocking Housing

Many pensioners are struggling with rising costs for groceries, insurance, energy, and healthcare, even though home ownership remains relatively high among older Australians.

The 2021 Census recorded around 9.8 million occupied dwellings containing approximately 31 million bedrooms. According to QUT researcher, Dr Lyndall Bryant , around 13 million of those bedrooms are underutilised, suggesting significant scope to make better use of existing housing, including homes owned by older Australians.

But how?

One option is to remove financial disincentives that discourage pensioners from renting out a spare room or temporarily renting out their home when they are not living in it.

The current situation

The home a person lives in is generally exempt from the Age Pension assets test. Pensioners can also be absent from their principal residence for up to 12 months in most circumstances and continue to have it treated as their exempt home, provided they intend to return.

However, if they rent out a room or earn income by renting out their home while they are away, that rental income is generally counted under the Age Pension income test.

As a result, some pensioners may decide the additional income is not worth the pension reduction, along with the costs and responsibilities of being a landlord.

Much of the debate about housing and retirement incomes focuses on including the family home in the Age Pension means test. However, another approach is to explore ways to better utilise existing housing stock.

A different way of thinking about the problem

Forcing people to downsize is unlikely to appeal to many Australians. Providing incentives and additional choices may be a more practical approach.

Consider a widow living alone in a four-bedroom home. She may be willing to rent a room to a student, key worker, or another older person, but be concerned about the effect on her pension.

Or consider a retired couple travelling around Australia, spending extended periods with family interstate, or temporarily living overseas. Renting out their home while away could help cover costs, but current pension rules may reduce the financial benefit of doing so.

In many cases, homes and spare bedrooms remain unused because the rewards of renting them out are limited.

What is the policy idea?

Bryant has suggested two broad options:

  • Reduce the impact of rental income on the Age Pension means test
  • Remove Capital Gains Tax barriers associated with renting out a home.

This Policy Lab focuses on the first idea - exempting some or all rental income from the Age Pension income test where the income comes from:

  • Renting out one or more rooms in a principal residence; or
  • Renting out an entire home while temporarily living elsewhere.

Under this model, pensioners would continue to receive their Age Pension entitlement while retaining rental income, which would remain taxable under normal taxation rules.

The aim would be to encourage more people to make spare rooms and temporarily vacant homes available to renters, increasing housing supply without requiring new construction.

More housing without building a single new home

Unlike large housing developments, existing homes are available today.

If even a small proportion of pensioner homeowners rented out a spare room or temporarily rented out their home while it would otherwise sit empty, thousands of additional accommodation opportunities could become available.

Every occupied spare room reduces pressure on the wider rental market.

There could also be benefits for older Australians. An additional $200 to $400 a week in rental income could help many households meet rising living costs and improve financial security without requiring them to move.

Tackling loneliness and isolation

The benefits may not be purely financial.

Social isolation is an increasing concern for many older Australians, particularly those living alone after the loss of a partner.

Sharing a home can provide companionship, improved security, and regular social interaction for both parties.

A more flexible policy could also support a broader range of lifestyle choices, including:

  • Living with relatives for extended periods, including those needing care and support
  • Spending time travelling around Australia
  • Living overseas with family or to reduce living costs (this has the added benefit of reducing domestic inflation)
  • Experimenting with different living arrangements before making a permanent move.

But won't this cost the government?

The main concern is that exempting rental income could increase Age Pension expenditure.

However, this assumes large numbers of pensioners are already renting out spare rooms or homes and having their pensions reduced as a result. Evidence suggests this is not that common.

If current pension rules discourage participation, a targeted exemption may have limited budgetary impact while encouraging housing that is currently unavailable to enter the rental market. Government would also benefit from the tax raised from rental income.

Appropriate safeguards could help ensure the policy remains focused on housing outcomes and supporting older Australians with limited means. These could include:

  • Restricting eligibility to long-term residential rentals
  • Excluding short-stay and holiday accommodation such as Airbnb
  • Requiring minimum rental periods
  • Limiting the exemption to a principal residence
  • Restricting eligibility to people who own only one home
  • Introducing income caps.

These measures could help ensure the policy remains targeted, fair, and fiscally responsible.

An idea worth exploring?

Making better use of existing housing stock will not solve Australia's housing shortage on its own. New housing construction will still be needed.

However, encouraging pensioners to rent unused rooms or temporarily vacant homes could increase housing supply, boost retirement incomes, reduce loneliness and support ageing in place.

If a relatively small policy change could unlock thousands of bedrooms that already exist, it may be worth serious consideration.

To help us understand whether this idea has merit, complete the poll below and join our Better Housing campaign to support more innovative solutions to Australia's housing challenges.

Poll


Author

Dr Brendon Radford

Dr Brendon Radford

Director of Policy and Research, National Seniors Australia

/Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.