Geneva – The imposition of life sentences and lengthy prison terms on dozens of Shia clerics, preachers, and religious chanters in Bahrain, amid violations of defence rights and the absence of an independent and effective investigation into allegations of torture and coerced confessions, undermines fair trial guarantees and the integrity of the judgments. Counterterrorism does not justify violating the ban on torture, fair-trial guarantees, freedom of religion or belief, or the prohibition on discrimination. A conviction requires proof of individual responsibility based on lawful evidence, and those convicted must be able to appeal and seek redress.
On 16 November, Bahrain's High Criminal Court sentenced 64 people to life in prison and five others to 15 years in prison, convicting all 69 defendants in the case. They included 60 Shia clerics and nine people working in religious affairs, including religious chanters. The court also fined some of those convicted 100,000 Bahraini dinars (approximately $265,000) and ordered the confiscation of more than eight million dinars (approximately $21.2 million) listed for charitable purposes.
According to human rights reports, the judgments covered 56 people in detention, including mosque imams, preachers, directors of religious institutes, and chanters. Among the most prominent were Mohammed Sanqour and Ali Al-Saddadi, who had led prayers at Imam Sadiq Mosque in Diraz, along with Majeed Al-Mashaal, Mahmoud Al-Ali, Mousa Jawad Al-Wadaei, Mohammed Saeed Al-Tatoun, Mohammed Hadi Al Gharifi, Fadel Al-Zaki, Ali Al-Mustarshid, Aziz Al-Khadran, and Mahdi Sahwan. Another 13 clerics were sentenced in absentia, several of whom live outside Bahrain. Among the most prominent were Abdullah Al-Daqaq, Hussein Al-Daihi, and Ali Al-Jufairi, as well as Isa Ahmed Qassim, who has lived abroad since 2018, after his nationality was revoked in 2016.
The case began on 9 May with Bahraini security forces conducting arrests and night raids targeting dozens of clerics, amid regional military escalation and Iranian attacks on United States military sites and vital and industrial facilities in Bahrain since late February. Judicial proceedings must remain independent of political and security concerns. Prosecutions must be based only on specific acts for which each defendant's responsibility is established by lawful evidence, without assuming responsibility based on sectarian affiliation or religious belief.
According to legal sources familiar with the case, the court initially set 8 November for issuing its judgment, then postponed it to 22 November before moving the session forward to the morning of 16 November at the Public Prosecution's request. Defence lawyers were not notified by telephone until around 5:00 PM the previous day. Procedural transparency and fair-trial guarantees require an explanation for this acceleration and protection of the defendants' rights. The scheduling and rescheduling of hearings must be guided by the requirements of justice, while safeguarding the court's independence and impartiality and shielding its decisions from political or security pressure or influence.
Human rights and legal sources report that the prosecution cited religious sermons and lectures, teaching and fundraising activities, and communications with religious authorities abroad as evidence. The judgments should undergo independent and effective judicial review to verify that the convictions rest on acts meeting the elements of specific offences, and that legally protected beliefs or religious practices have not been criminalised. The review must also guarantee the defence's right to challenge the evidence and contest its relevance to each convicted person's individual responsibility.
Facts presented in several human rights reports, along with statements attributed to detainees and their relatives, describe practices that constitute torture and other cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment. These practices included holding some detainees incommunicado; questioning them at the General Directorate of Criminal Investigation and Forensic Science without their lawyers present; restraining their hands and blindfolding them for days; forcing them to stand for prolonged periods; depriving them of sleep; beating them; stripping them; threatening sexual assault against their family members; threatening to revoke their nationality and deport them; and threatening some with the fate of Mohammad Al-Mousawi, who died in custody last March amid suspicions that he had been tortured.
An immediate, independent, and effective investigation into these incidents is essential to protect complainants, witnesses, and their families from intimidation and retaliation. Any statements or confessions obtained through torture or coercion must be excluded and not relied on for conviction. A defendant's signature on an interrogation record does not prove that the statements were made voluntarily; the authorities bear the burden of proving voluntariness.
Several reports described deteriorating physical and psychological conditions among detainees held at the Criminal Investigation building and Dry Dock Detention Centre, along with complaints that they had not received necessary medical care. Mohammed Al-Tatoun reported being forced to stand with his hands restrained and eyes blindfolded for an entire week, despite suffering from haematuria and kidney stones, and being denied necessary surgery.
Local sources also reported that Isa Al-Mumin was experiencing tremors, Ali Saleem was using a wheelchair, and Ali Al-Mustarshid had been physically assaulted and transferred to solitary confinement in early October.
Bahraini authorities are responsible for detainees' safety. They must promptly provide medical examinations and specialised treatment, investigate any denial of care or assault, ensure detainees maintain contact with their families and lawyers, and notify them of any transfer to another place of detention.
According to human rights and legal sources familiar with the defendants' statements, the pressure continued through the investigation stage before the Public Prosecution. Several detainees said their appearances before prosecutors lasted only a few minutes, after which they were forced to sign prepared records without being allowed to read them, under threat of being returned to the Criminal Investigation holding cells.
According to accounts shared by human rights sources, Mohammed Al-Tatoun, 62, said his interrogation before the Public Prosecution lasted no more than five minutes. He later found records containing more than 150 questions and answers attributed to him, most of which, he said, had not been asked or given during the interrogation. Mohammed Sanqour gave similar testimony before the court. The sources also noted repeated, identical wording and paragraphs appearing verbatim in interrogation records for different detainees. These facts warrant verification of the records' authenticity, how they were prepared, and whether they reflect the defendants' actual statements, since this bears on both the accuracy of the statements and whether those statements were made voluntarily.
The trial proceedings violated the defendants' right to an effective defence. Their lawyers could not obtain copies of the case files and were limited to reviewing them in person and taking handwritten notes within tight timeframes. The court rejected requests for detainees to appear in person, requiring them to participate by video link despite complaints that the sound was lowered or cut off as they described the circumstances of their interrogation. Their families were also barred from attending the hearings. These practices undermined fair trial guarantees, particularly the right to sufficient time and facilities to prepare a defence; defendants' ability to present their statements and challenge evidence; confidential communication with their lawyers; and the principle of public hearings.
Trying 69 people in one case does not relieve the court of its duty to verify each defendant's responsibility, assess the evidence against them, and address their defence arguments. The prosecution's evidence cannot be treated as applying generally, and no defendant can be held responsible for another's acts. Any sentence must also reflect the defendant's established role in the offence and individual circumstances, in keeping with the principles of individual criminal responsibility and individualised sentencing.
Interpreting counterterrorism provisions broadly to criminalise beliefs or lawful religious practices violates the principle of legality in criminal law. This principle requires offences to be defined precisely and clearly and prohibits expanding criminal liability by analogy. Affiliation with a religious authority outside the country does not, by itself, establish criminal responsibility. Any restrictions on expression or the manifestation of religion or belief must be prescribed by law, meet the requirements of necessity and proportionality, and serve a legitimate purpose, in accordance with the safeguards applicable to each right under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. The freedom to hold a belief, however, remains immune from any restriction.
Torture and other cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment are absolutely prohibited under Article 7 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the Convention against Torture. They cannot be justified by war, an emergency, or counterterrorism requirements. When there are reasonable grounds to believe that torture occurred, authorities must promptly conduct an independent and effective investigation, even without a formal complaint, and protect complainants and witnesses from intimidation and retaliation, in accordance with Articles 12 and 13 of the Convention against Torture. A detainee cannot be required to produce evidence held exclusively by the detaining authority. Nor may missing interrogation recordings be used as a pretext to close an investigation before all other means of proof have been exhausted.
When a confession is challenged on the grounds of torture or coercion, the authorities must prove it was given voluntarily. A defendant's signature or repetition of the confession before the Public Prosecution does not cure the defect while the effects of coercion persist.
Statements obtained through these means must be excluded, and judgments based on them must be reviewed under Articles 7 and 14 of the Covenant and Article 15 of the Convention against Torture. Article 19(d) of the Bahraini Constitution likewise affirms that statements and confessions made under torture, degrading treatment, or threats thereof are invalid.
Incommunicado detention, denial of access to legal counsel, and restrictions on the defence's access to case files undermine the guarantees in Articles 9 and 14 of the Covenant and the United Nations Basic Principles on the Role of Lawyers. These guarantees require defendants to communicate confidentially with their lawyers; have adequate time and facilities to prepare their defence and challenge evidence; benefit from the presumption of innocence; and have their conviction and sentence reviewed by a higher tribunal under Article 14(5). They are consistent with Article 20 of the Bahraini Constitution, which addresses the personal nature of punishment, the presumption of innocence, the prohibition on harming the accused, and the right to a defence.
Denying necessary medical care and subjecting detainees to degrading conditions violate the duty under Article 10 of the Covenant to treat them humanely and respect their dignity. The Nelson Mandela Rules set out the requirements for fulfilling this duty, including access to specialised treatment and independent medical decision-making. Remedying violations involves more than stopping them; it also requires investigation, accountability, and guarantees of redress, compensation, and rehabilitation, pursuant to Article 2(3) of the Covenant and Article 14 of the Convention against Torture.
The case comes within a broader security campaign Bahrain has witnessed since the outbreak of regional escalation. According to human rights reports, the campaign included the arrest of more than 700 people and the revocation of nationality from 69 citizens on 27 April, including 33 children, according to documentation by the Bahrain Institute for Rights and Democracy and Human Rights Watch, in addition to deportation measures.
These incidents are separate from the case of the 69 defendants, and security considerations do not permit arbitrary arrest or arbitrary deprivation of nationality, nor do they exempt the authorities from protecting children's right to nationality and preserving their identity under Articles 7 and 8 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child.
Having acceded to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights in 2006, Bahrain is obligated to protect freedom of religion or belief, freedom of expression, and equality before the law under Articles 18, 19, and 26. Sectarian affiliation may not be used as a basis for suspicion or discriminatory treatment, nor may security measures be expanded to encompass practices protected by law. Effective means must be available to challenge measures affecting rights and obtain remedy for their consequences, while judicial independence and impartiality must be preserved in their review.
The Bahraini authorities must overturn the convictions and sentences issued following trials that did not meet the guarantees of justice, drop charges based on the peaceful exercise of rights, and immediately and unconditionally release those detained on that basis. Any retrial must be based on charges concerning acts criminalised by clear and legally compliant provisions and on lawful evidence, before an independent and impartial court that guarantees defence rights and public proceedings, with statements obtained through torture, ill-treatment, or coercion excluded, and without using a retrial as a justification for continuing arbitrary detention.
All those convicted and their lawyers must be provided with copies of reasoned judgments, case files, and hearing records, and be enabled to effectively appeal convictions and sentences before a higher court through a review covering the facts, sufficiency of evidence, and correctness of the application of the law. Those convicted in absentia must be given sufficient time and facilities to prepare appeals and communicate confidentially with lawyers, so they can be retried when their rights to notification and defence were not respected. Independent observers must also be allowed to monitor the proceedings.
An immediate, independent, impartial, and effective investigation is imperative into allegations of torture, ill-treatment, coercion, and concealment of places of detention, as well as the circumstances surrounding the deletion or loss of interrogation records. The investigation should be conducted by a body independent of the authorities and of those under investigation, and should examine the responsibility of everyone who committed, ordered, or concealed violations, including members of the security services, members of the Public Prosecution, and others. Anyone against whom sufficient evidence exists should be referred for prosecution and be guaranteed not to escape accountability.
Surveillance and interrogation recordings, detention records, medical files, and other evidence must be preserved and made accessible to independent investigative bodies. Also, independent medical and psychological examinations must be conducted with the detainees' consent and in accordance with the Istanbul Protocol. Complainants, witnesses, their families, and lawyers must be protected from intimidation and retaliation, and victims must be guaranteed reparation, including compensation, rehabilitation, and guarantees of non-recurrence. Furthermore, the confiscated funds must be returned if the legal basis for their confiscation is annulled.
Urgent and specialised medical care must be provided to all detainees who require it; incommunicado detention must end; regular contact with families and lawyers must be guaranteed; detainees must be informed of the place of detention and any subsequent transfer; and independent monitoring of detention facilities must be allowed. Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor calls for a review of counterterrorism laws and how they are applied, to ensure offences are clearly defined, and the laws are not used to criminalise beliefs, expression, or religious activity protected by law.
Arbitrary decisions to deprive people of their nationality must be reversed, and nationality restored to those affected. They must also be guaranteed the right to appeal and obtain redress, while children must be protected from losing their nationality or having their identity affected by acts attributed to family members.
The United Nations mechanisms responsible for freedom of religion or belief, torture, the independence of judges and lawyers, and arbitrary detention should follow up on the case, raise it with the authorities, and request visits to the detainees. All states with close ties to Bahrain should publicly call for these measures to be implemented, monitor the detainees' conditions and the safeguards surrounding their trials, and follow up on appeals against their judgments.