HRW Urges Action on Lethal Autonomous Weapons at CCW Review

Human Rights Watch

Thank you Chair,

The Review Conference taking place this week is one of the most consequential moments for human rights and humanitarian protection of our times, as you will decide whether to begin negotiations on new legal rules governing autonomous weapons.

Along with Stop Killer Robots and our hundreds of partners around the world, Human Rights Watch is urging high contracting parties to take concrete steps toward the negotiation of a legally binding instrument prohibiting certain types of autonomous weapons systems and regulating others. At such a critical juncture, nothing short of a time-bound mandate to negotiate a legally binding protocol will adequately protect civilians from this rapidly developing and potentially devastating technology.

Autonomous weapons systems pose a wide range of ethical, moral, legal, humanitarian, and security risks. Their widespread use risks eroding accountability mechanisms for violations of international human rights and humanitarian law as well as undermining the legal restraints that minimize harm to civilians and damage to critical infrastructure in armed conflict.

After more than a decade of discussions, the Group of Governmental Experts (GGE) on Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems (LAWS) has clarified the core issues, paving the way for negotiations of a robust new protocol.

The adoption of the GGE's final report, setting out the "elements of an instrument," could serve as the basis for negotiating new legal rules. There is also value in many other proposals and working papers that have been submitted to the GGE over the years, and high contracting parties should seek to bring them into the new mandate so valuable ideas and work can be carried forward and debated.

At the Seventh Review Conference of the CCW in November, we respectfully urge states to:

  • Adopt a one-year negotiation mandate on an additional protocol to the CCW to prohibit and regulate autonomous weapons systems;
  • ⁠Ensure the inclusion and participation of civil society actors throughout the Review Conference, and reach an agreement to return this meeting to a formal session as soon as possible so that the deliberations will be public and on the record.

Any proposal short of a negotiation of new law would condemn governments to years of more talk while sidestepping the urgent action needed to address the grave humanitarian and human rights threats posed by autonomous weapons systems. It would fall dramatically short of what is needed to protect civilians and preserve accountability for life-and-death decisions in warfare. Existing international humanitarian law remains vital, but it was never designed to deal with weapons systems that can select and engage targets without meaningful human control.

At a time when military investments in autonomy are accelerating and the risks are becoming more acute by the day, states should be negotiating a legally binding treaty with clear prohibitions and safeguards. The international community needs binding rules before these weapons proliferate further, not a roadmap for continued delay.

The CCW was designed to respond to the humanitarian threats posed by established and new weapons technologies. Indeed, its preamble reaffirms the "need to continue … the progressive development of the rules of international law applicable in armed conflict." This Review Conference can demonstrate that it can still achieve these goals. At a time of deep and concerning geopolitical instability, the responsibility rests with high contracting parties to act.

Thank you.

/Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.