Effectively combating hate crime requires the consistent identification and systematic recording by law enforcement and justice systems of information on the biases that motivated the perpetrators, the OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR) said today as it released its annual Hate Crime Report .
"Accurate information on bias motivations behind hate crimes facilitates their effective investigation and prosecution, while also providing the evidence needed to develop targeted prevention policies," said ODIHR Director Maria Telalian. "Systematically recording these motivations is a necessary step in efforts to better protect communities targeted by hate crimes and ensure justice for individual victims."
Hate crimes are criminal offences committed with a bias motivation against people or property based on their actual or perceived association with a group sharing an identity characteristic (such as national or ethnic origin, religion, disability, gender identity or sexual orientation, among others).
On this International Day for Tolerance, ODIHR encouraged national authorities to record bias motivations at each stage of a criminal justice process, make this data public, and use this data to inform effective responses. Based on information reported to the Office, this 22nd annual Hate Crime Report reveals that bias motivations are recorded by police in only 30 out of the 40 OSCE participating States that submitted their official statistics to ODIHR this year, with further gaps in recording by prosecutors and courts.
The report identifies a number of instances where hate crimes might go unrecorded as such, including gaps in national crime recording systems or cases where the bias motivation for a particular crime is not included in the characteristics protected under national legislation. In such cases, the experiences of affected communities risk going unrecognized and unaddressed.
Furthermore, some recording systems allow only one bias motivation to be recorded, even when victims of hate crime are often targeted on multiple grounds. Comprehensive information on these overlapping motivations is needed to better understand patterns of hate crimes and to design effective criminal justice responses.
Broad bias motivation categories, such as "race", ethnicity or religion, also may lack the level of detail needed to identify which communities are most affected by hate crime. For example, recording hate crimes under the broad category of "religion" alone may not show whether Jewish, Muslim, Christian or other religious communities are being targeted, making it harder for authorities to identify specific patterns of victimization and develop appropriate, evidence-based measures to protect affected communities.
ODIHR's dedicated hate crime website comprises consolidated information and data on hate crimes reported by OSCE participating States, civil society and international organizations, including data disaggregated by bias motivation, where available.