The analysis issued by the Parliamentary Budget Office (PBO) of the Resources Super Profits Tax (RSPT) at the request of the Greens is pure conjecture and its assumption that a giant new mining tax would have no impact on mining company behaviour is clearly nonsensical.
In their rush to demonise and vilify the mining sector as part of their class warfare crusade, the Greens have once again exposed themselves as economically illiterate.
If you tax something more, you get less of it.
The benefits flowing to all Australians through company tax and royalties from Australian minerals operations in 2026 derive from investments made after May 2010 and would not have occurred had a combined tax rate of 58% applied to future profits.
The RSPT failed to strike the right balance in sharing mining returns between investors, who bear most risk, and the government and took a heavy toll on mine cash flows despite the popular theory that the new tax would not affect future investment, a claim made by the government at the time.
Indeed, the PBO's earlier 2021 analysis of the same issue, requested by Adam Bandt MP, explicitly warned that behavioural responses, production, prices and exchange rates created "considerable uncertainty" and could significantly affect estimated revenue.
Yet the updated analysis, requested by David Shoebridge and covering a longer period, does not include the same explicit qualification and in fact assumes that the RSPT would not have changed mining investment, production or mineral prices.
This erroneous assumption means that the PBO revenue estimate does not capture the likelihood that weaker exploration and investment would have materially reduced future production, taxable rents and RSPT revenue.
Australia's company tax rate is already one of the highest in the world before accounting for state mining royalties.
Adding an RSPT would have further increased the tax burden and materially weakened Australia's international competitiveness for exploration, project development and investment.
The RSPT also failed to gain traction because of key attributes that could not be supported under any reasonable analysis.