
People seeking advice about depression and anxiety from community-based Reddit groups are often encouraged to get professional help, but a new Flinders University study has found that some responses to people in crisis lack clear next steps or the urgency recommended by clinical guidelines.
Published in the Journal of Medical Internet Research, the study examined 1,065 posts and their highest-ranked visible responses in Reddit's popular 'r/mentalhealth' community. Researchers compared actionable advice with established international and Australian clinical guidance.
The most common recommendation posted on Reddit for both depression and anxiety was for people to seek professional help, along with suggestions about returning to daily activities in small steps, building healthy routines, managing difficult emotions and reaching out for social support - which also frequently reflected clinical guidance.
An estimated one in five Australians experience a mental illness at some stage, and digital platforms and peer support are often people's first point of call before seeking professional help.

Senior Lecturer in Healthcare Management at Flinders University, Dr Peivand Bastani, says the Reddit study findings highlight the potential contribution of online peer support.
"An encouraging finding was how often people directed each other towards professional help," says senior author and research supervisor Dr Bastani.
"Many highly-ranked replies also offered practical suggestions consistent with clinical guidance, such as taking small steps to reconnect with everyday activities and seeking support from others."
The study also identified advice being shared that was not consistently aligned with clinical recommendations, involving complex relationships, some approaches to self-management and crisis situations.
"Some responses recognised that people needed help but were less clear about how urgently they needed it or what they should do next," says Dr Bastani.
"This gives online communities and moderators something practical to consider. How can they make routes to professional and urgent support clearer when people disclose serious distress?"
First and corresponding author Dr Yu Takizawa, a lecturer in mental health at Flinders University, says the findings need to be understood within the study's scope.
"We examined the highest-ranked visible response to each post, which gives us a picture of advice receiving prominent community endorsement," says Dr Takizawa, a member of the Flinders Institute for Mental Health and Wellbeing.
"Our findings suggest these responses can offer guidance consistent with clinical recommendations. Further research is needed to understand how people use that advice and whether it influences their decisions to seek help," he says
The researchers analysed posts collected over approximately one month in a single English-language Reddit community. They assessed the content of advice without measuring changes in users' behaviour or mental health outcomes.
The study highlights opportunities to support online peer communities through clearer guidance for responding to complex and urgent situations.
Read the paper - 'Evidence-based alignment of Reddit peer advice for depression and anxiety: Qualitative content analysis (2026) by Yu Takizawa, Ehsan Abedin, Joanne Glover and Peivand Bastani - published in the open-access Journal of Medical Internet Research (JMIR Publications). DOI: 10.2196/92971