We know young people in Australia and worldwide are experiencing growing mental health challenges.
Authors
- Scarlett Smout
Postdoctoral Research Fellow at The Matilda Centre for Research in Mental Health and Substance Use and Australia's Mental Health Think Tank, University of Sydney
- Katrina Champion
Senior Research Fellow & Sydney Horizon Fellow, The Matilda Centre for Research in Mental Health and Substance Use and School of Public Health, University of Sydney
The most recent national survey from the Australian Bureau of Statistics found nearly two in five (38.8%) 16- to 24-year-olds experienced symptoms of a mental disorder in the previous 12 months.
This was substantially higher than the last time the survey was run in 2007 , when the figure was 26%.
We've published a new study today looking at the rates of mental health problems among Australian high school students specifically. We found almost one in four high school students report mental health problems by Year 10 - and things are worse for girls and gender-diverse teens.
Tracking teens' mental health
In our study , published in the Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health, we looked at mental health symptoms in more than 6,500 Australian teens, and how these symptoms changed over time.
We surveyed high school students from 71 schools annually from Year 7 (age 12/13) to Year 10 (age 15/16). Our sample, while not nationally representative, includes a large cross-section of schools in New South Wales, Queensland and Western Australia.
We found symptoms of mental health problems increased steadily over time:
- in Year 7, 17% of students we surveyed reported symptoms which met the criteria for probable depression, increasing to 28% by Year 10
- some 14% of students reported high psychological distress in Year 7, rising to 24% in Year 10
- the proportion reporting moderate-to-severe anxiety grew from 16% in Year 7 to 24% by Year 10.
Which teens were hardest hit?
We looked at how mental health symptoms over time were linked to different social factors, such as gender, cultural background and family affluence. We also looked at school factors, such as how advantaged a student's school is.
We found clear differences in mental health by gender, affluence, and school advantage. Girls and gender diverse teens had higher symptoms in Year 7 and a steeper rise in symptoms over the four years, when compared to their male peers.
By Year 10, compared to males, females had average symptom scores that were 88% higher for depression, 34% higher for anxiety, and 55% higher for psychological distress (in models that adjusted for other factors).
Again compared to males and in adjusted models, gender diverse teens had symptom scores at Year 10 that were 121% higher for depression, 55% higher for anxiety, and 89% higher for psychological distress.
Teens from the least affluent families had 7% higher depressive symptoms than those from the most affluent families in adjusted models, while teens attending the least advantaged schools had 9% higher anxiety symptoms than teens attending the most advantaged schools.
We then examined how gender and affluence interacted to influence mental health. Girls in the lowest affluence group experienced heightened anxiety and depressive symptoms over and above the effects of affluence or gender alone.
This shows how multiple factors can stack up, creating greater risk of poor mental health for certain young people.
While we were able to explore a wide range of factors, a limitation of our study was that we could not examine all social factors that may impact mental health. For example, we couldn't ascertain the potential differences experienced by Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander teens or those living in remote and very remote areas.
How does this data compare to other studies?
Recent Australian data from similar-aged adolescents is scarce. However, the 2015 Young Minds Matter study found 14.4% of 12- to 17-year-olds experienced a mental disorder in the prior 12 months.
The higher rates of mental health challenges we observed in our study are likely consistent with recent evidence suggesting "cohort effects" - where each generation has worse mental health than the one before it. Research is still investigating the reasons behind these trends, with avenues of inquiry spanning everything from social media to climate change. But it appears no single factor is to blame.
The COVID pandemic has also played a role, with young people seeming to be hit particularly hard by mental health impacts of the pandemic.
Notably, the gender differences between girls and boys are supported by data from global studies , showing this is not a uniquely Australian phenomenon.
What can we do about the gender divide in mental health?
With a mental health-care system stretched beyond capacity, it's crucial we prevent and address mental health problems early. While this requires a multilayered approach, aiming to reduce these gender inequities in mental health is an important place to start.
While outside the scope of this study, a growing field of research is interrogating why there are gender differences in mental health. Factors identified include:
- experiences of gender-based violence
- gender differences in lifestyle behaviours (for example, diet, physical activity and screen time)
- gendered norms that place pressure on girls to meet unrealistic gender standards
- gender differences in family and social relationships
- biological differences related to hormones and menstruation.
These areas indicate avenues for potential solutions, but addressing these factors requires wraparound investment.
Promisingly, many of these factors are mentioned in the National Women's Health Strategy . With women's health a central platform for the Albanese government's election campaign, hopefully we will see more investment in research and policy to address these issues.
Importantly, our study found gender inequities in mental health were even more stark for gender diverse teens, so focus should not solely be on girls and women.
We must design solutions with young people
Adolescent mental health isn't something we can tackle with a one-size-fits-all approach. We need strategies that are meaningfully co-designed with young people themselves. Initiatives can then be tailored to meet their unique needs and reflect their diverse experiences.
When we work directly with priority groups, such as girls, gender diverse teens and those experiencing socio-economic disadvantage, we can offer safe, culturally appropriate and affirming solutions. This helps teens feel seen, heard and supported - all key ingredients for better mental health.
If this article has raised issues for you, or if you're concerned about someone you know, call Lifeline on 13 11 14 or Kids Helpline on 1800 55 1800.
Scarlett Smout receives funding from the BHP Foundation and provides academic support for Australia's Mental Health Think Tank.
Katrina Champion receives funding from the Medical Research Future Fund and via University of Sydney Horizon Fellowship.
