Dangerous Road Design, Not Bad Drivers, Is Problem

As the UK marks Road Safety Week 2026 , Ian Loader, Professor of Criminology in the Faculty of Law , argues that reducing casualties means looking beyond punishment of individuals and redesigning the car-centred systems and streets that make serious harms possible.

In 2025, 1.16 million people around the world were killed in road collisions . That's 3,178 deaths per day. Up to 50 million were injured.

Traffic collisions are the biggest global killer of children and young people aged 5 to 29. And in the UK alone in 2025, 1,594 people were killed on the roads - more than 4 per day. Over 29,000 were seriously injured.

This maiming and death is socially and spatiality patterned. The risk is greater in low- and middle-income countries (the exception is the US, where, as of 2022, pedestrian fatalities had spiked by 83% since 2010 and were at a 40-year high ). Across the world, you are more likely to be injured or killed in a traffic collision if you are poor, a child or elderly, and if you are a pedestrian, cyclist or motorcyclist.

For the most part, the harms of car-centric transport and mobility systems are normalised. We accept death on the road at a scale we would judge unacceptable in other settings.

Why punishing bad drivers isn't enough

Criminal law gets its response to road harm all wrong. It focuses on the responsibility of the individual driver and targets the minority who cause injury while driving dangerously, carelessly, or while inebriated or distracted. In doing so, the law communicates the reassuring message to everyone else that driving is basically safe.

The courts then sentence that minority of convicted 'bad' drivers to standard forms of punishment (fines, community service or prison), while neglecting the question of how to reduce future driving risk. I call this phenomenon 'motonormative punishment'.

Law struggles, in short, to bridge the chasm between the risk created by two-tonne steel machines moving through busy, fleshy environments and the absence of intent to commit harm. The law serves to reproduce the normality of driving and its many criminal and wider harms.

Five ways to make our roads safer

In research published this year in the British Journal of Criminology, I argue that we need to re-frame road safety as a matter of environmental regulation . That means we should stop treating the harms caused by cars as isolated accidents or crimes, and instead make our streets safer by redesigning the wider environments, systems and rules that allow these harms to happen.

I outline 5 principles that flow from making this paradigm shift. Let's call them the 5 Ds of road violence reduction.

  1. Diversion: taking measures to reduce the number of vehicles on our roads and miles driven, and to maximise alternatives to private cars.
  2. Design: creating urban environments and vehicles with the purpose of reducing the risk of injury and death (slower speeds, restrictions on where cars can go, reformatting dangerous junctions, and regulation to encourage smaller vehicles).
  3. Distributed agency: this sounds complicated, but it simply means extending responsibility for (reducing) road violence beyond the individual driver to all relevant actors and objects in a system. That includes car manufacturers, advertisers, traffic engineers, public health professionals, police and so on.
  4. Deliberative learning: responding to road injury and death by publicly grieving the loss of life and by forming inquiries that bring together all affected parties (the driver, victims' families and road safety activists) and implicated actors. These inquiries need to focus on the question 'why did this happen and how can we stop it happening again?'
  5. Disassembling dangerous actants: another one that sounds complicated - this means that we should separate the dangerous combination of driver and vehicle. Careless or dangerous driving should have consequences, but sentencers should first focus on reducing future risk by breaking up the human-machine hybrid. This requires a mix of measures aimed at the human driver (licence suspension and revocation, which we should use earlier, more often, and for extended periods in the most serious cases) and at vehicle adaptation (installing black boxes and intelligent speed assistance) or removal (asset forfeiture).

Road deaths are not inevitable

The law's focus on punishing errant individual motorists is one of the ways in which car harms are normalised and the systemic harms of car-centric mobility are obscured.

While drivers who cause harm should of course continue to be held responsible, we must also recognise that the thousands of people killed and seriously injured on our roads each year are not simply the unfortunate price we have to pay for getting around - and nor are they solely the product of a minority of bad drivers.

Head and shoulders image of Professor Ian Loader for Find an Expert
"These tragedies are the predictable and preventable result of choices we make about the number and nature of vehicles on our streets, how those streets are designed, and how we think about people's safety and freedom."

It's time we took road violence much more seriously. If we are to do so, criminal law and punishment needs to take a back seat.

/University Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.