Employment Non-Discrimination Laws Cut Manufacturing Waste

Penn State

UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Discussions of legislative policies that promote fairer workplaces, such as Employment Non-Discrimination Acts (ENDAs), have often revolved around their social and cultural merits, but recent scholarship has suggested they can lead to a wide range of broader economic benefits as well, including reducing turnover rates and increasing productivity and innovation . Now, a new study led by Penn State researchers has found that ENDAs are associated with significant environmental impacts as well, reducing manufacturing process waste by nearly 10% at firms who reported to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in states that adopted such policies.

According to the researchers, who examined 33 years of data on more than 8,000 facilities across the U.S. and reported their findings in the journal Production and Operations Management , the link between ENDAs and manufacturing waste arises due to two shifts: an increase in the diversity of workplace perspectives and a greater sense of "psychological safety" for employees. This sense of safety increases the likelihood that employees will speak up when they notice an issue or an improvement opportunity, the researchers said.

"Research tells us that if you want to learn, if you want to contribute, you should feel safe," said co-author Suresh Muthulingam , professor of supply chain management at Penn State's Smeal College of Business. "If you are in a stressed-out environment, it is difficult to do that. So, this sense of psychological safety creates an environment where people can voice their ideas, which can lead to improvements in operations."

The researchers found that firms had 57% higher odds of modifications to their manufacturing processes after ENDA enactment and roughly 74% higher odds of relying on internal knowledge when making these changes, potentially reducing the need for external knowledge that may lack the intimate insights gleaned from firsthand experience on the factory floor.

"Since there were more diverse people in the plant due to these acts — and they felt safer working in that environment — they were more likely to share ideas or question things that might be a bit unconventional or against the mainstream," said co-author Kevin Linderman , professor of supply chain management and chair of Smeal's Department of Supply Chain and Information Systems. "This actually helps the firm learn and improve more over time."

To analyze the impact of ENDAs on manufacturing process waste, the researchers leveraged data from the Environmental Protection Agency's Toxic Release Inventory , which tracks the release of a wide range of chemicals as well as the steps facilities take to reduce pollution on-site. The researchers said they focused on process waste specifically because it is shaped by a litany of decisions around process design and efficiency, highlighting the intersection between environmental performance and operations quality. In total, the study examined 8,670 distinct manufacturing facilities under 1,112 parent firms between 1987 and 2019, comparing the changes that occurred in states that enacted ENDAs to those that had not yet adopted the policies.

Though Title VII of the Civil Right Act of 1964 provided employment protections based on race, color, religion and national origin, there was essentially no federal basis for prohibiting discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity until the law was broadened to include those factors as a result of the 2020 Supreme Court decision in Bostock v. Clayton, the researchers noted. To fill that gap, they said, many states enacted ENDAs over the years to codify those expanded protections.

The staggered adoption of these policies provided the researchers with the conditions for a natural experiment that could help control for other national and regional economic shifts that might have affected manufacturing processes. They also included data from the Correlates of State Policy Project , which compiles state-level policy and socioeconomic data across more than 100 years, to separate the effects of ENDA adoption from the wider state policy landscapes, particularly other major environmental and labor policy changes.

"We conducted a battery of robustness checks to ensure there were no pre-existing trends before the policy change, no anticipation of the policies, and that we were accurately capturing the timing of the impacts," said co-author Max Ji , an assistant professor of management at the University College Dublin and a doctoral candidate in Smeal's Department of Supply Chain and Information Systems.

The researchers conducted two separate analyses on the effects of ENDA enactment: a facility-level analysis that explored the effects on individual manufacturing plants within the states that adopted such policies as well as a firm-level analysis that focused on the broader parent companies whose headquarters were located there. Though much of the actual labor and process of production occurs at the facility level, the researchers said they were surprised to find that ENDA enactment had an even greater effect at the firm level, illustrating the impact that changes coming from top management can have across an organization. In addition to the fact that firms might oversee several facilities spread across different states, allowing them to exert broader influence, Muthulingam noted that an increase in diversity at the managerial level and beyond is an important driving force behind these impacts.

"Sometimes it's not easy to look at a solution or identify a problem unless you have different viewpoints," he said. "A more diverse set of people voicing their opinions helps you to surface the problems and possibly identify solutions that can improve your processes."

The researchers noted that this study and its findings fit neatly within a few emerging threads in operations management research that emphasize the value of incorporating societal and employee welfare in measures of an organization's success. This growing body of research provides evidence for a more humanistic alternative to business models driven largely by efficiency.

For Muthulingam, the idea is simple: If firms take care of their employees and create a more inclusive workplace, then it will benefit the firms.

"At the end of the day, we are not just machines," he said. "With machines, you can just focus on efficiency, but humans need a little bit more. They need to feel wanted. They need to feel included. They need a place where they can voice their ideas. And all of these elements have positive outcomes for operations within organizations."

Suvrat Dhanorkar of Georgia Tech's Scheller College of Business was a co-author on the study.

/Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.