Why Punishment Doesn't Always Deter Crime

University of California - San Diego

From three-strikes laws to longer prison sentences, we impose harsher penalties in the hope they'll reduce crime. But decades of research show that increasing punishment often does surprisingly little. What if we're missing something crucial?

New research from the University of California San Diego suggests one potentially overlooked reason: people's moral motivations for breaking the law in the first place.

Across 10 studies published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), researchers at UC San Diego's Rady School of Management found that people acting from a perceived moral motivation were less deterred by punishment than those motivated primarily by material gain.

"People sometimes commit crimes because they feel morally compelled to right a wrong. Or they might be retaliating, punishing someone, defending their honor," said Raihan Alam, a Rady School doctoral student and National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellow who conducted the research with psychologist Tage Rai, an assistant professor of management at Rady. "That doesn't mean their behavior is justified. It means they're acting on motives that don't fit neatly into a cost-benefit calculation."

Putting Motives to the Test

The researchers began by analyzing federal crime data on more than 30,000 offenders across 29 categories of crime. They found that crimes perceived as more morally motivated were associated with higher rearrest rates, while those perceived as more materially motivated were associated with lower rates. The analysis relied on study participants' assessments of likely motives, rather than offenders' own accounts, so the findings are correlational.

The researchers then tested the role of motivation more directly, holding the illegal behavior constant while changing the reason for committing it.

In one experiment involving 422 people, participants imagined blocking traffic either to support a cause they believed in or in exchange for money. Those who imagined they were acting for a cause were less deterred by the possible consequences. The pattern held in other experimental scenarios – and across financial penalties, physical harm or social disapproval.

Finally, the researchers tested their hypothesis in economic games involving real money. One player ended up with all the game's available money, either by deliberately keeping it or through a random allocation. Another player could then, at the risk of a financial penalty, redistribute the money evenly.

In the absence of a possible financial penalty, participants were similarly willing to redistribute the money whether the uneven split was deliberate or random. However, when facing a possible penalty, participants were about 20 percentage points more likely to redistribute when the unequal split was deliberate. The difference suggests that people are more willing to risk punishment when they believe they're righting a wrong.

"Taken together, our findings show that when people are motivated by moral sentiments to commit crimes or transgress, they tend to be less sensitive to punishment than when they're acting for material or selfish reasons," said Rai.

Rethinking Crime Prevention

One common explanation for punishment's limited effectiveness puts the problem with offenders themselves: poor self-control, faulty judgment or an inability to weigh consequences.

Critically, Alam and Rai also ran their core studies with participants who had prior misdemeanor or felony convictions. The results were remarkably similar to those from the general population. That suggests the problem may lie less with offenders' ability to weigh consequences than with our assumptions about what motivates people.

Successful crime prevention may require addressing offenders' underlying motivations, rather than simply increasing penalties, Alam and Rai suggest. Although their studies did not directly test it, they point to restorative justice – which focuses on repairing harm and relationships – as one possible approach.

The research also underscores a fundamental question: What do we want punishment to accomplish?

"If we're punishing people because we want retribution against those who've done harm, if that's what we want, then punishment's fine," Rai said. "But if the goal is actually to change behavior, then punishment may not be the best tool for the job."

The research was funded in part by an NSF Graduate Research Fellowship to Alam. For more, read the full paper in PNAS: " Morally motivated crimes are less sensitive to punishment ."

/Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.