Mandatory Minimums Add 10 Months to Prison Terms, Study Finds

'These policies have huge impacts on people's lives. We can think about that, as an economist would say, as impacting their utility, or, as a layperson may say, their happiness. But, from a pure dollar and cents framework, it's quite expensive'

The prisoner handles the prison in jail

(Adobe photo)

Racial minorities facing federal drug charges have allegations of conspiracy added to their cases at higher rates than their white counterparts, as prosecutors seek to push them over the threshold for a mandatory minimum sentence that then can be used in negotiating stiffer penalties, a new UConn study finds.

Defendants have about 10 months added to their prison sentences, the study adds, thanks to mandatory minimum sentencing laws that require a person to spend at least five or 10 years in jail, depending on the amount of drug they're charged with carrying.

Over 97% of federal drug cases are resolved via plea bargain, but because defendants face significant minimum sentences, the study says prosecutors use that to their advantage when making offers of jail time.

"It's all about that leverage," says Spencer Cooper, an assistant professor in UConn's Department of Economics whose study "How much do mandatory minimums matter?" looked at all federal drug trafficking cases from 2010 to 2021. "Mandatory minimum sentencing gives prosecutors so much leverage that they can add almost a year to someone's sentence. Pair that with this idea that prosecutors are pushing minorities toward mandatory minimum sentences more frequently, and we start to have a real concern."

The study was published this fall in The Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization.

In it, Cooper explains that prosecutors are allowed to manipulate drug quantities during the judicial process if they can find additional evidence or are able to connect individual cases. That means a person found with a drug amount at arrest just below the threshold for a minimum sentence could face more serious charges and increased penalties when their case appears in court.

Conspiracy charges are a common way to push a person into a minimum sentence threshold, he says. A person found with 999 grams of powdered cocaine, for instance, and eligible for the five-year minimum sentence, suddenly faces the possibility of 10 years in prison if they're connected to another defendant and the drug amount rises just 1 gram to 1,000 grams.

"One of the big controversies of this law and what some previous research has noted is that the mandatory minimum sentencing statute seems to be a driver of race disparity in sentencing. There seems to be something about it that causes minorities especially to get longer sentences," Cooper says. "I wanted to see if this was coming from the statute or from this idea of prosecutors moving people. The answer is that it's prosecutors moving people. They are choosing to move Black and Hispanic people into that eligibility through conspiracy more frequently."

It's a finding that was surprising, he says.

Sure, drug dealers seek to move as much product as possible to maximize their profits, but logically one would assume they know the law and would keep their trafficking amounts just under mandatory minimums, he says.

"Instead, we're seeing that people are right at the threshold. They're carrying the exact amount needed for mandatory sentences," Cooper says. "And that's coming from the discretionary actions of these prosecutors. The statute itself isn't driving the gaps between racial groups. It is the decisions being made by these legal actors and the way in which they are using the law as a bargaining chip."

'Crime is incredibly costly'

In 2024, the federal prison system operated at 10% over capacity, Cooper says, describing an overcrowding problem that's unique to the United States. Added to the lack of prisoner beds are the problems of understaffing and cost of incarceration, which is about $44,000 per person annually.

In the 1980s and 1990s, he adds, lawmakers enacted stiff drug penalties, so much so that today 45% of the total federal prison population comprises drug offenders, in part a result of mandatory minimum sentences.

Cooper acknowledges this paper doesn't look at whether or how eliminating minimum sentences affects things like crime rates and recidivism - those are questions for upcoming research. This study, though, is a way to spark conversation among policy and lawmakers about how mandatory minimums impacts people, he says.

One thing that particularly concerns him is the so-called "safety valve" that's codified in statute, which seeks to protect those who are first- or second-time offenders or who have only misdemeanors on their records. Simplified, the safety valve is supposed to shield low-level individuals from facing stiff sentences.

But Cooper's study finds that it doesn't. These offenders still see harsher sentences than one would expect.

"I think that would be a real concern for policymakers," he says. "We're trying to give a safety valve for these people who are low offenders, but they're still not immune."

He continues, "All these policies have huge impacts on people's lives. We can think about that, as an economist would say, as impacting their utility, or, as a layperson may say, their happiness. But, from a pure dollar and cents framework, it's quite expensive. Crime is incredibly costly. We have to find an optimum of how much we want to pay for enforcement and how much we want to pay to have these court cases. We also have to figure out how we can make court cases shorter, so they're not so expensive. All these things have a really big impact."

/Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.