GENEVA - There is no rationale for the continued detention of Sikh British national, Jagtar Singh Johal, who was abducted during a visit to India to get married, and has now spent over eight years - 3089 days - in prison without a foreseeable end to his case, UN experts* said today.
"Eight and a half years of arbitrary detention without a clear path to trial is not justice, it is unlawful suffering," the experts said. "The prolonged uncertainty alone is a form of psychological torture."
Johal, a human rights defender, was seized in Punjab in November 2017 not long after his wedding, by hooded men later identified as police officers, and taken to an undisclosed location where he was held incommunicado for 10 days. During that time, it is alleged that he was subjected to electric shocks, stress positions, sleep deprivation and threats of being killed.
He was later charged in a series of terrorism-related offences, some carrying the death penalty, and which reportedly relied on confessions extracted under torture. In March 2025, a court acquitted him in one of the charges, finding no reliable evidence. Yet Johal remains behind bars.
"The fact that he was acquitted, yet still faces near-identical charges, raises serious concerns about double jeopardy, the presumption of innocence, the misuse of counter-terrorism laws, and the integrity of the proceedings," the experts said. "This is not simply delay - it points to deeper dysfunction in the administration of justice."
According to recent reports, Johal's conditions have worsened. He has faced restrictions on contact with his family, limited access to basic hygiene, and periods of solitary confinement.
"International law is unequivocal: torture includes severe mental suffering caused by prolonged uncertainty while awaiting trial," the experts said. "It also prohibits the use of evidence obtained through torture in proceedings, and requires prompt, transparent and fair trials," they said.
"This case represents the cumulative impact of injustice", the experts said. "The reliance on contested evidence, multiplication of proceedings on near-identical charges, allegations that he was targeted because of his faith, his continued arbitrary detention and the absence of accountability for torture allegations reflect a profound miscarriage of justice."
They called on the Government of India to drop the remaining charges, release Johal without delay and conduct a full, prompt and independent investigation into the allegations of torture and ill-treatment and the misadministration of justice.
"Time is not neutral," the experts said. "The long wait for an outcome has already caused intolerable anxiety and stress, and constitutes an unacceptable harm prohibited under international human rights law."
The experts have sent a new communication on Johan's case and will monitor developments.
