A major report released today has revealed that many Australian babies are being placed at unnecessary risk because their birth by caesarean section is scheduled too early, without a medical reason. This is despite clear evidence that waiting until 39 weeks – unless there is a medical reason not to – is best for the baby.
Around half (between 43% and 56%) of planned caesarean section births performed before 39 weeks in 2017 did not have a medical or obstetric reason, potentially putting many newborns at unnecessary risk. Of particular concern, 13% to 19% of all planned caesarean sections performed before 37 weeks did not have a recorded medical or obstetric reason.
These are some of the key findings of the Fourth Australian Atlas of Healthcare Variation, produced by the Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care in partnership with the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare.
Launched today by the Minister for Health and Aged Care, the Hon Greg Hunt MP, the Fourth Australian Atlas of Healthcare Variation maps healthcare use across the country and identifies potentially unwarranted variation and areas for healthcare improvement.
The report examines 17 items across six clinical topics: early planned births; potentially preventable hospitalisations for chronic disease and infection; ear, nose and throat surgery in children and young people; lumbar spinal surgery; gastrointestinal investigations; and medicines use in older people.
Best for baby – waiting until 39 weeks
Guest speaker at the launch today, Professor John Newnham AM, Senior Australian of the Year 2020 and Professor in Obstetrics & Gynaecology at The University of Western Australia, explained that births before 39 weeks are considered early.
“While at times early birth is necessary, all too often it occurs without a medical or obstetric reason,” he said.
“The evidence is clear that waiting until at least 39 weeks is best for the baby’s development, unless there is a medical reason for an earlier birth.”
Unnecessary early birth can have a range of consequences, from higher risks of respiratory problems at birth to higher risks of behavioural and learning problems in the long-term, Professor Newnham explained.
“Every week counts towards the end of pregnancy” he advised, adding that the risks to the newborn are greater at 37 than 38 weeks, and greater at 38 than 39 weeks.
Factors likely to influence the rates of early planned births include how the birth is funded, the hospital’s location, operating theatre capacity, organisational culture, and policies and guidelines.
To address the issue, the fourth Atlas recommends universal changes to government, hospital and insurer policies to stop booking of planned births before 39 weeks without a medical or obstetric indication.
Policy change is essential, according to Professor Newnham.
“It is also important for parents to have accurate information about the risks and benefits of early planned birth, and access to clinicians and facilities at the right time,” he said.
“I encourage parents to ask questions before booking an early caesarean section, to make sure their birth plans are best for both mother and baby.”
Higher hospitalisations in remote and socioeconomically disadvantaged areas
In addition to high rates of early planned birth, the fourth Atlas uncovered high rates of potentially preventable hospitalisations among those living in remote and socioeconomically disadvantaged areas, and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples.
This was the case for all five conditions examined in the Atlas: chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), kidney infections and urinary tract infections, cellulitis, heart failure, and diabetes complications.
The Atlas reports that there were more than 330,000 potentially preventable hospitalisations in Australia due to these five conditions in 2017-18.
Hospitalisation for COPD had the highest geographic variation, with an 18-fold difference between the highest rate (1,013 per 100,000 in Katherine, NT) and the lowest rate (56 per 100,000 in Pennant Hills-Epping, NSW).
The Commission’s Acting Chief Medical Officer, and host of the Atlas launch event, Conjoint Professor Anne Duggan, said many of these hospitalisations could be prevented by the implementation of evidence-based care plans that ensure earlier intervention, better disease management and better coordination of care.
“There is a significant workforce shortage in rural and remote areas, not only of doctors and nurses, but of allied health professionals,” she said.
“Social determinants of health such as nutrition and housing also play a role in hospitalisations for some of these conditions, and it’s incredibly important for people to have a GP at the centre of their care.”
Also speaking at the launch, Commission Board Chair Professor Villis Marshall AC and Australian Government Department of Health Chief Medical Officer Professor Paul Kelly, discussed the Atlas findings and recommendations, and how they can be used to improve healthcare equity in Australia.