New University of Bristol-led research presented at the European Congress on Obesity (ECO) in Maastricht, the Netherlands (4-7 May), has found that just three per cent of adults with a recording of overweight or obesity in England are referred to weight management programmes by their GP.
National obesity guidance was introduced in England at the end of 2006, with a 2014 update stating that adults with a BMI of ≥25 (≥23.0 in minority ethnic groups) are eligible for referral to a lifestyle weight management programme. These programmes focus on making behaviour changes to eating and physical activity habits.
GPs can also refer patients with severe and complex obesity to specialist weight management services including bariatric surgery.
Weight management programmes are known to be effective, but availability varies across the country, and, with no national registry of non-surgical weight management interventions, it isn’t clear how many people are getting the opportunity to access them.
Dr Karen Coulman and colleagues at the University of Bristol used anonymised primary care electronic health records to establish how many adults with overweight and obesity receive referrals to weight management programmes (lifestyle and specialist weight management programmes).
They also looked at the characteristics of the patients who received referrals and of the GP practices making the referrals. Their analysis showed 31.1 per cent (1,811,587) of the adults whose records were studied had a recording of overweight or obesity in primary care between January 2007 (just after the first national obesity guidance was published) and June 2020.
This is half the latest Health Survey for England estimate that 64 per cent of adults have overweight or obesity1 and indicates that overweight and obesity are being under-reported in primary care.
Dr Coulman, of Population Health Sciences, Bristol Medical School, University of Bristol, said: “This is likely to be due to multiple factors, for example the requirement to have a register of patients with BMI ≥30 was only added to the Quality and Outcomes Framework (QOF) in 2017; pressures within primary care; and the need for more training in obesity for primary care professionals.
“Further research is needed to investigate this finding, however, the current Enhanced Service Specification for weight management2 should help improve recording of weight in primary care.”
The cross-sectional study also found that only 3.1 per cent (56,783) of those with a recording of overweight or obesity received a referral to a weight management programme.
Men had 31 per cent odds of receiving a referral than women and people aged 18-24 had 54 per cent lower odds than those aged 45-54.
People with Black ethnicity had 23 per cent greater odds of being referred than those with White ethnicity.
Adults diagnosed with obesity or overweight in more recent years were more likely to be referred. The odds of being referred were 2.7 times higher for those diagnosed in 2019-20 compared with those diagnosed in 2007.
A higher BMI also increased the likelihood of a referral. Those with a BMI of 40-plus had a more than six times greater odds of being referred than those with a BMI of 25-29.9 kg/m2.
Adults living in the most deprived areas had 20 per cent greater odds of being referred than those in the least deprived areas, which may be reflective of the link between obesity and deprivation.
People with type 2 diabetes however, had 11 per cent lower odds of being given a referral than those without the condition. Those with heart disease and hypertension had 20 per cent and 27 per cent lower odds of being referred, respectively.
The researchers said this may be because these groups are being referred to lifestyle programmes tailored to their condition. Such programmes normally include advice on diet and exercise. However, more research is needed to confirm this.
There were no differences in referral rates between rural and urban GP practices but there were differences across regions.
The odds of referral were highest in the West Midlands, where people were more than twice as likely to be referred than those in the North West.
Dr Coulman says: “Weight management programmes are known to be effective and national guidance states that anyone with overweight or obesity is eligible to be referred to one.
“Our research shows that not only is overweight and obesity being under-reported in primary care but just three per cent of those who were given a recorded diagnosis of overweight or obesity between 2007 and 2020 received a referral for weight management.
“We are undertaking research interviews with health professionals and patients to understand the reasons for this.”