People in the Netherlands sometimes face waiting lists of several months for mental healthcare. But for some people with mental health problems, the delays start even earlier. Research by Leiden University Medical Center (LUMC) shows that GPs sometimes have to refer patients multiple times before they find the right care.
More than two referrals are needed for over one in five patients before they receive appropriate mental healthcare. This happens far less often in other medical specialties. In the most extreme cases, patients were referred more than twenty times. These are the findings of an analysis by Iris Boonstra, a PhD researcher at LUMC.
'Long waiting times in mental healthcare are a well-known and visible problem. But before people even get there, they often go through a lengthy process, for example involving their GP or a practice nurse. This means that the total waiting time may actually be much longer than the official figures suggest', says Boonstra.
Making a hidden problem visible through data
For her research, Boonstra used data from the regional ELAN data network, which makes information from different parts of the healthcare system securely and anonymously available for research. The network contains data from GPs, hospitals and other healthcare organisations in the The Hague, Leiden and Zoetermeer region.
By combining these data, researchers can track patients' care pathways over longer periods of time. This reveals patterns that individual healthcare organisations often cannot see on their own. For example, a GP knows which referrals have been made, while a mental healthcare provider knows which patients eventually start treatment. ELAN makes it possible to link these data and give researchers a more complete picture.
Actual waiting time is longer
For her research, Boonstra followed what happened after a GP referred someone to mental healthcare. Was another referral made soon after the first one? How often did this happen? And which patients were most affected?
The results show that GPs need to make multiple referrals more often for patients who require mental healthcare than for patients who, for example, are referred to a cardiologist or an internal medicine specialist. This can delay access to the right care.
This additional waiting time is often not reflected in official waiting list figures. Waiting times are usually only recorded from the moment someone is placed on a waiting list. The time spent trying to reach that point is therefore often overlooked.
Boonstra's analysis shows that not all patients are equally likely to get stuck in the system. GPs need to make more referrals before young adults aged 18 to 40 with complex mental health conditions receive care.
Not every problem fits into a box
But why do GPs so often have to make a new referral? According to Boonstra, one possible explanation is that mental healthcare is divided into many different specialisms. 'There are so many separate categories, but many people don't fit into just one.'
Dennis Mook-Kanamori, a GP and LUMC researcher specialising in Population Health Management, recognises the same pattern: 'Adult psychiatry is very much divided into separate silos.'
As a GP, he sees how patients with complex problems are passed from one healthcare provider to another, without their treatment ever really getting started. 'It's like a hot potato effect: people keep being passed around without anyone actually helping them.'
Working together to find solutions
The analysis shows which patients get stuck in the system. The next question is why this happens. Mook-Kanamori explains: 'Data helps us identify patterns that would otherwise remain hidden. But numbers alone don't tell the whole story.'
To find out more, the researchers want to talk to GPs, mental healthcare providers and other stakeholders. The data show where the bottlenecks are. The next step is to understand the decisions, working methods and circumstances behind them.
According to Mook-Kanamori this is in line with the Population Health Management approach: first use data to identify a problem, then work with the people involved to find its causes and possible solutions. 'First, you need to understand the problem. Who is affected? Which population are we talking about? Only then can you start looking at what is needed to solve it.'
Looking beyond the medical problem
ELAN also offers opportunities for further research. Researchers can combine healthcare data with information about people's living environments. This will allow them to investigate whether factors such as ethnicity, income, debt or housing conditions play a role in making it harder to find appropriate care. 'Then you realise that this is not just a medical problem, but also a social one', says Mook-Kanamori.
The researchers hope these insights will ultimately lead to better care for people who currently get stuck between different healthcare providers. After all, the better we understand where things go wrong, the more effectively care can be improved.