A groundbreaking study led by Monash University and the Victorian Institute of Forensic Medicine has provided new insights into Coward Punch offences in Australia. This research, published in the journal Medicine, Science and the Law, explores the profiles of offenders, the circumstances of these incidents, and the judicial outcomes.
The study, conducted by Dr Reena Sarkar and Associate Professor Jennifer Schumann, analysed 287 convictions for Coward Punch incidents over a thirty-year span from 1990 to 2020. Key findings include:
- The vast majority of offenders were male, with a median age of 26.
- 61% of cases were prosecuted in New South Wales and Victoria.
- Sentences for manslaughter convictions ranged from 3.8 to 11.5 years.
- 62% of offenders received prison sentences, while 19.5% were given community-based sentences.
- Self-defence was a successful argument in 2.1% of cases.
- Most incidents (65%) occurred in public places, predominantly between 6 pm and 6 am.
Coward Punch assaults typically involve a single punch to the face, neck, or head, causing the victim to fall and sustain further head injuries from striking the ground or another hard surface. These injuries can lead to severe disability or death.
Dr Sarkar explained, "Our research highlights that Coward Punch assaults often happen in public settings and during late hours, indicating a need for targeted interventions in these environments." Associate Professor Schumann added, "Understanding the characteristics and outcomes of these cases can help shape more effective legal and public health strategies to prevent such tragedies."
The study also noted that alcohol was a factor in 39% of cases, while illicit drugs were involved in less than 2%, and no substance abuse was reported in nearly 20% of cases.
Danny Green, the founder of the Coward Punch campaign, stressed the importance of changing the terminology used to describe these attacks. "Using the term 'Coward Punch' attaches a strong negative connotation to a despicable act, serving as a deterrent," Green said. "Through continuous education and awareness, we can reduce the occurrence of Coward Punch attacks in our communities."
Legal responses to Coward Punch incidents vary across Australia. Western Australia was the first to introduce specific legislation in 2008, followed by the Northern Territory in 2012, and Victoria, Queensland, and New South Wales in 2014. However, similar laws are not yet in place in South Australia, the Australian Capital Territory, or Tasmania.
The authors of the study pointed out that the introduction of Coward Punch legislation was both a legal and a public statement aimed at raising social awareness. "Alongside these laws, changes in liquor regulations and public health campaigns have also played a role in addressing Coward Punch violence," Associate Professor Schumann noted.
This research aims to enhance the effectiveness of anti-violence education and inform future strategies to combat Coward Punch incidents.
Read the full paper in: Medicine, Science and Law. An analysis of offence patterns and legal response to one-punch fatalities in Australia. DOI: 10.1177/00258024251316669.
