ST. LOUIS – Public health experts have long recognized social isolation as a profound health risk. The COVID-19 pandemic brought that risk into sharper focus. The abrupt disruption in community life created an unprecedented natural experiment in serious social deprivation, providing an opportunity for researchers to examine how changes in social participation were associated with older adults' cognitive and mental health.
In new findings published in The Journals of Gerontology, Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences, Saint Louis University researchers and colleagues found that older adults who stopped participating in community activities during the pandemic showed poorer cognitive functioning in 2022 than those who remained engaged.
Encouragingly, older adults who had not participated in community activities before the pandemic but began doing so during it had cognitive functioning comparable to those who remained consistently engaged.
SangNam Ahn, Ph.D., associate professor of health management and policy in the College for Public Health and Social Justice at Saint Louis University and the study's lead author, noted that changes in social participation were not significantly associated with depressive symptoms in 2022.
"Older adults' emotional well-being appeared resilient, while their cognitive functioning may have been more vulnerable," Ahn said. "The concerning finding was that older adults who stopped participating in community activities had cognitive outcomes resembling those of adults who had remained isolated."
Older adults already faced an elevated risk of social disconnection before the pandemic. Although many may have maintained contact with family and friends during the shutdowns, the pandemic disrupted a different source of connection: community-based activities such as volunteering, attending clubs, taking courses and participating in public organizations. Early research documented immediate effects such as loneliness, anxiety and depressive symptoms, but the longer-term cognitive and mental-health consequences remained less clear.
Researchers analyzed nationally representative longitudinal data from the Health and Retirement Study, using analytic samples of 2,457 older adults for depressive symptoms and 1,679 for cognitive function from a 2016 pre-pandemic baseline through pandemic-era participation in 2020 and cognitive and mental-health follow-up in 2022.
The researchers grouped participants into four trajectories:
Consistently isolated: Did not participate in community activities in either 2016 or 2020
Pandemic drop-off: Participated in 2016 but not in 2020
Consistently engaged: Participated at both time points
Pandemic initiators: Did not participate in 2016 but began doing so by 2020
The study measured participation in volunteer work, educational courses, charitable activities, social, sports or hobby clubs and nonreligious organizations.
After accounting for participants' previous health and demographic characteristics, the researchers found no significant association between social-participation trajectories and depressive symptoms in 2022. Cognitive differences, however, persisted. The pandemic drop-off group had significantly poorer cognitive functioning than the consistently engaged group, with scores resembling those of adults who had been consistently isolated. Pandemic initiators had cognitive functioning comparable to consistently engaged adults.
In a secondary analysis, the researchers found preliminary evidence that initiating social participation may have been especially beneficial for adults with a greater cumulative number of adverse childhood experiences.
Taken together, the findings suggest that sustaining or initiating community participation may be one modifiable way to support cognitive health in later life. They also add support to social prescribing, an emerging practice in which health care providers connect patients with opportunities for community engagement such as volunteer opportunities, courses, clubs, charitable activities and community organizations.
Based on the findings, Ahn argues that social engagement should be treated as a component of preventive health care.
"With social prescribing and patient and family education on the importance of sustained social engagement, we may be able to support cognitive reserve and reduce the long-term cognitive consequences of social isolation," Ahn said. "Social engagement deserves greater attention as a component of preventive health care."
Other authors of the study are Thommas E. Burroughs, Ph.D., of Saint Louis University, and Joonhyung Lee, Ph.D., of the University of Memphis.
About Saint Louis University
Founded in 1818, Saint Louis University is one of the nation's oldest and most prestigious Catholic research institutions. Rooted in Jesuit values and its pioneering history as the first university west of the Mississippi River, SLU offers more than 12,000 students a rigorous, transformative education that challenges and prepares them for lives of purpose. As a nationally recognized leader in research and innovation, SLU is an R1 research university, advancing groundbreaking, life-changing discoveries that promote the greater good.