UNSW Professor Jessica Grisham is sharing practical strategies to help health professionals support people with severe hoarding who are not ready to engage in conventional treatment.
For people experiencing severe hoarding, the prospect of having their possessions removed can prevent them from seeking help, even when their living conditions pose serious health and safety risks.
Cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT) is the first line treatment for hoarding, but some people with hoarding difficulties are unwilling or unable to engage with CBT. For these individuals, Professor Jessica Grisham from UNSW Sydney's School of Psychology advocates a harm reduction approach that puts the person first, builds motivation over time and supports practical changes to make their home safer.
"We're not aiming for a perfectly clear home. We're working with people to make their homes safer, while helping them live independently in a home they can continue to call their own," says Prof. Grisham.
The approach is being shared with health professionals involved in NSW Health's Pathways to Community Living Initiative (PCLI). The program aims to support people with mental illness to live safely and independently in their own homes, while reducing the risk of homelessness, hospitalisation, fire and other serious harms.
Around 50 mental health professionals from the PCLI network will take part in a workshop led by Prof. Grisham and other specialists on 17 November. The participants include psychologists, psychiatrists and social workers who lead teams supporting people in the community.
Prof. Grisham says an estimated up to two-thirds of people with hoarding disorder do not recover after receiving CBT, making it important for services to have other ways to reduce risks and maintain contact.
Practical strategies of harm reduction approach:
- Embrace a different mindset. The focus isn't on clearing out the home or discarding possessions, it is on making the home safer and more comfortable for that person.
- Engaging and motivating without pushing. Build trust and work collaboratively. Work at the person's pace with them in charge of every decision. Stay curious instead of persuading and explore mixed feelings about change.
- Assess risk and decide how to respond. Use standardised tools to assess whether a situation is imminent, moderate or low risk, and use them to guide decision-making.
- Use practical strategies. Choose safety targets first (exits, fire risks, a usable bed and kitchen), make sessions short and manageable, maintain focus on specific areas, take before-and-after photos to celebrate progress.
- Work with others. Coordinate practical support. Bring together health, housing and community services when specialist assistance is needed.
Making homes safer, one change at a time
The harm reduction approach focuses on identifying and reducing the most urgent risks.
These might include blocked exits, unsafe electrical connections, fire hazards, mould, infestations or the inability to safely use essential areas such as the kitchen or bathroom.
People are involved in deciding which risks to address first and what changes would help them live more safely and comfortably.
"If there's a pile of newspapers in front of a heater, or their exit is blocked, we might work with them to focus on that particular area," Prof. Grisham says.
The approach may involve working gradually through one part of the home, using practical tools to assess risks and measuring changes over time. It may also involve housing, cleaning or other community services that can provide the physical support needed to remove items safely.
Understanding the person behind the possessions
Prof. Grisham says one of the most important shifts for health professionals is to focus on the person, rather than the possessions.
People with hoarding disorder may have experienced trauma, grief, social isolation or other mental health challenges. They may also feel shame about their living conditions and fear that services will judge them or remove their possessions without their consent.
"If you come in and say, 'I need to clear out your papers and books', you meet with so much resistance," she says.
"But if you're interested in why someone has held on to those things and what they mean to them, you have a chance to build trust and work towards their goals."
For example, someone who holds on to newspapers because they value knowledge, writing or journalism may be supported to find other ways to maintain those interests, rather than being told simply to throw the newspapers away.
The upcoming workshop will begin with a contribution from a woman with lived experience of hoarding.
She will speak about her experiences of hoarding treatment, the challenges she has faced and how her relationship with hoarding has changed as she has grown older.
"Having someone with lived experience open the workshop sets the tone for the entire day. It reminds us that we're working with people, not simply responding to what we see in their homes, and that their experiences and goals need to guide the support we provide," says Prof. Grisham.
Hearing directly from someone with lived experience can help health professionals understand the emotional significance of possessions, the impact of stigma and the patience required to support lasting change.
Why forced clean-outs can backfire
Prof. Grisham says forced clean-outs are generally ineffective for two main reasons: they can cause serious distress, and they do not give people the skills, motivation or support needed to change their behaviour.
"Forced clean-outs can lead to enormous distress, anxiety and trauma," she says.
"They can also rupture relationships. And if you clear out someone's house without helping them learn anything new or giving them a reason to live differently, they will usually start re-accumulating."
In some situations, a forced clean-out may be unavoidable because of an immediate and serious risk to the person or others. But Prof. Grisham says it should be considered a last resort, rather than the default response.
"A gradual, collaborative approach may also reduce costs associated with repeated clean-outs and other interventions," Prof. Grisham says.
Working together to prevent a crisis
Hoarding can create overlapping mental health, physical health, housing and safety concerns, which means no single service can address the problem alone.
Prof. Grisham says the most effective response combines psychological support with practical help from housing, public health, community and other services.
"Just coming to see a clinical psychologist in an office isn't going to help with some of the physical tasks ahead," she says.
"We need to pair psychological training and support with physical support and work with housing to help people remain safely in their homes."
The PCLI workshop will bring these different perspectives together, including expertise in clinical psychology, public health, hoarding, and lived experience.
Jo Sommer, Statewide Manager, Pathways to Community Living Initiative, NSW Health said, "The PCLI Network is excited to explore a new approach and build additional skills that will strengthen their ability to support people to live meaningful and fulfilling lives in their communities."
By bringing together UNSW clinical expertise, practical support and lived experience, the workshop aims to give health professionals more options for helping people who may otherwise struggle to access appropriate care.
Prof. Grisham says the goal is to ensure people experiencing severe hoarding receive support before their living conditions become a crisis.
"People experiencing hoarding can easily fall through the cracks because they are not always able to advocate for themselves. We need to make sure the right support is available before a crisis occurs."