The origins of extremely high-energy particles that fill the Universe - such as protons, electrons, and neutrinos - remain one of the longest-standing mysteries in modern astrophysics. A leading hypothesis suggests that "explosive transients," including massive stellar explosions (supernovae) and tidal disruption events (TDE) caused by stars being torn apart by black holes, could be the cosmic engines driving these energetic particles. Yet, this idea has never been rigorously tested.
A research team has conducted the first systematic search for optical counterparts to a neutrino "multiplet," a rare event in which multiple high-energy neutrinos are detected from the same direction within a short period. The event was observed by the IceCube Neutrino Observatory, a massive detector buried deep within the Antarctic ice.
The team was led by Seiji Toshikage, a graduate student at Tohoku University's Graduate School of Science, Shigeo Kimura, a professor at Tohoku University's Frontier Research Institute for Interdisciplinary Sciences (FRIS), and Masaomi Tanaka, also from the Tohoku University's Graduate School of Science.
By analyzing wide-field optical data that coincided both spatially and temporally with the neutrino multiplet, the researchers sought visible evidence of possible astrophysical sources. However, their investigation found no supernovae, TDEs, or other explosive transients at the corresponding times and positions.
This absence of optical counterparts is, paradoxically, highly informative. The non-detection allows the team to place stronger constraints than ever before on how bright and how long such explosive events could be if they were to produce neutrino multiplets. The findings significantly narrow the possible origins of the Universe's most energetic particles and mark an important step toward solving one of astrophysics' most fundamental puzzles.
"Although we didn't find any transient sources this time, our results show that even non-detections can provide powerful insights," said Toshikage. "They help us refine our models and guide future searches for the true sources of high-energy neutrinos."
Looking ahead, the team plans to conduct rapid optical follow-up observations of newly detected neutrino multiplets as soon as the IceCube collaboration reports them. They expect that these efforts, building on the analysis methods developed in this study, will bring researchers closer to identifying the astrophysical engines that generate high-energy particles throughout the cosmos.
The study was published in The Astrophysical Journal on October 23, 2025.
- Publication Details:
Title: The First Search for Astronomical Transient as a Counterpart of a Month-timescale IceCube Neutrino Multiplet Event
Authors: Seiji Toshikage, Shigeo S. Kimura, Nobuhiro Shimizu, Masaomi Tanaka, Shigeru Yoshida, Wataru Iwakiri, Tomoki Morokuma
Journal: The Astrophysical Journal
