People often claim that "regulation holds Europe back". On 12 November 2026, researchers and policy experts met in the Rechtenkamer of the Academy Building for a one-day workshop on "Europe's Adaptive Capacity in the Age of AI: Rights, Regulation, and Geopolitical Constraint" to test that claim. They discussed whether Europe's rights-based way of governing technology slows its response to AI and a shifting geopolitical landscape, or whether it is a source of strength.
Three faculties, one question
In some areas, rights-based protection may slow adaptation or make public actors overly cautious. In others, Europe's regulatory model may give it legitimacy, stability and a long-term strategic advantage. The aim was to find out which holds where, and what it would take for Europe to adapt faster without giving up on rights.
The workshop was a joint initiative of three Leiden faculties, brought together by the Leiden University Europe Hub. The organisers were Matthew di Giuseppe and Babak Rezaeedaryakenari (Faculty of Social and Behavioural Sciences), Belle Beems and Melanie Fink (Faculty of Law), and Nora von Ingersleben-Seip (Faculty of Governance and Global Affairs). Each faculty convened one roundtable. Funding came from the Leiden University Europe Hub and from the Dutch Research Council (NWO) through the Veni grant Gateways for Humanity: The Duty to Reason in the Automated State (Melanie Fink, VI.Veni.231R.026).
The aim was not to present finished work but to think together across disciplines, so most of each roundtable was given over to open discussion. Beyond the day itself, the workshop sought to lay the foundations for a lasting network of researchers and policy experts in the Netherlands working on these questions. Besides the speakers listed below, participants included Maartje van Diest, Nikoleta Yordanova, Bernard Steunenberg and Fabienne Corvers.
Roundtable 1 - Too Slow to Adapt? Social Welfare, the Public Sector, and Europe's Capacity to Respond
Moderator: Matthew di Giuseppe
Speakers: Daan Juijn (Arq Foundation / Europe 2031), Vincent Homburg (Erasmus University Rotterdam), Juliana Chueri (VU Amsterdam), Freek Bomhof (TNO)
The first roundtable asked whether data protection, social protection and public-sector rules help or hinder adaptation in times of technological and geopolitical change. It also asked whether regulatory burden really limits European competitiveness, or whether it is a convenient explanation for deeper problems such as fragmented capital markets and energy costs.
The discussion made clear that Europe is slow to develop and adopt AI across the entire technology stack, and that this carries risks. Yet the law is only part of the explanation: other factors, such as data infrastructure and the state of European data spaces, matter as well. At the same time, speakers asked whether slowness might also be a strength, noting that pushback against AI is growing elsewhere too. Most importantly, the roundtable raised a more fundamental question: do we actually know where we are racing towards?
Roundtable 2 - More Rights, Less Protection? The Fragmentation of Rights in EU Digital Regulation
Moderators: Belle Beems and Melanie Fink
Speakers: Aurelia Colombi Ciacchi (University of Groningen), Anna Pivaty (Radboud University), João Pedro Quintais (University of Amsterdam), Gianclaudio Malgieri (Maastricht University), Maria-Lucia Rebrean (Leiden University), Tim Peute (Netherlands Institute for Human Rights)
The second roundtable looked at the growing number of sector-specific rights created by the GDPR, the Digital Services Act and the AI Act. Speakers opened by setting out what the EU digital acquis has gained for individual protection in their own field, from platform regulation to data protection and AI. The discussion then asked whether protection is shifting away from general principles, good administration and fundamental rights towards secondary law, and what may be lost along the way: interpretative flexibility, proportionality reasoning and constitutional weight. A second strand turned to enforcement. Many of the new rules respond to shortcomings that stem from weak enforcement rather than gaps in the law. Have the new frameworks solved those problems, or added a layer of complexity while leaving them in place?
So, does the individual stand stronger today than before the EU digital acquis? The panel saw real gains: the new rights are visible and people use them, some fill genuine gaps, and others turn broad principles into concrete entitlements. Yet that same concreteness creates problems. Spread across several instruments, rights are hard for individuals to navigate, and how they relate to one another is often unclear. Highly specific rights may even legitimise the practices they were meant to constrain. And, as one speaker put it, sectoral rights can have "flawed parents": where the original rights were not fully thought through, their offspring inherit the flaw.
Roundtable 3 - Desirable or Dangerous? International Cooperation on AI Governance
Speakers: Guangyu Qiao-Franco (Radboud University), Kristina Irion (University of Amsterdam), Miles Kellerman (Leiden University) and Daan Juijn (Arq Foundation / Europe 2031)
The final roundtable looked at Europe's place in a contested global order. It questioned the assumption that effective AI regulation requires global cooperation, and asked whether Europe should take a differentiated approach: global cooperation in some areas, selective cooperation in others, and regional frameworks where necessary.
The discussion showed just how complex this question is. Is there a shared sense of European values at all, and if so, what are they? And what do they mean for Europe's global partnerships? Speakers asked whether Europe could look beyond its traditional allies and pursue similar aims with other partners, including middle powers. They also considered which areas, such as critical infrastructure, Europe should protect to avoid heavy dependence on tech giants from the United States and China. Underlying it all was the question of how Europe can maintain its sovereignty.