Key Takeaways
- Compared with bicycle riders, injured e-scooter riders had a 10% higher adjusted risk of serious head or neck injury, despite having a slightly lower risk of severe or critical injury overall.
- Injured e-bike and bicycle riders had similar adjusted risks of severe or critical injury.
- Helmet use was documented for only 13% of e-scooter riders and about one-third of bicycle and e-bike riders. Across devices, helmet use was associated with a lower risk of severe injury and fewer craniofacial fractures.
CHICAGO — Adults injured while riding e-scooters had a higher risk of serious head or neck injury than those injured on bicycles, even though their injuries were less severe overall, according to a national trauma-center analysis published in the Journal of the American College of Surgeons (JACS). Injured e-bike and bicycle riders, meanwhile, had similar risks of severe or critical injury after researchers accounted for differences in rider and crash characteristics.
The study examined 47,102 adults treated at participating trauma centers in 2023 and 2024. It also found that helmet use was uncommon, especially among e-scooter riders, while alcohol intoxication was documented more often among injured e-scooter and e-bike riders than among bicycle riders. The findings come as cities and states respond to growing use of e-bikes and e-scooters and questions about how to keep riders safe .
"More and more people are using e-bikes and e-scooters for transportation and recreation. They're convenient, affordable, and can be great alternatives to driving, but they also pose distinct risks if not operated properly and with caution," said Behzad Abbasi, MD, lead author of the study and a postdoctoral fellow at the University of California, San Francisco. "How hospitals care for injured patients is important, and understanding these patterns can help hospitals improve patient care and prevent injuries."
Researchers used the American College of Surgeons National Trauma Data Bank® to compare injury severity, affected body regions, in-hospital deaths, and the use of services such as emergency surgery and blood transfusion. The database receives submissions from more than 900 emergency departments, trauma centers, and other institutions.
Study Findings
- Bicycles: Bicycle riders accounted for 32,100 cases (68%) and were the oldest group, with a median age of 54. Twenty-one percent had severe or critical injuries, and 3.2% died in the hospital.
- E-scooters: E-scooter riders accounted for 6,258 cases (13%). Sixteen percent had severe or critical injuries. Compared with bicycle riders, they had a 10% higher adjusted risk of serious head or neck injury, but a 7% lower adjusted risk of severe or critical injury overall. They also had lower adjusted risks of emergency surgery, early transfusion, and in-hospital death.
- E-bikes: E-bike riders accounted for 8,744 cases (19%). The number of recorded cases rose 44% from 2023 to 2024. Nineteen percent had severe or critical injuries; after adjustment, their risk of severe or critical injury did not differ significantly from that of bicycle riders.
Across devices, helmet use was associated with a 12% lower adjusted risk of severe injury and fewer craniofacial fractures, as well as a 69% lower adjusted risk of skull fracture and a 45% lower adjusted risk of facial fracture for e-scooter riders. However, helmet use was low among all riders, as it was documented for only 33% of bicycle riders, 32% of e-bike riders, and 13% of e-scooter riders.
A blood alcohol level of 0.08% or higher—the U.S. legal threshold for alcohol-impaired driving—was recorded for 19% of injured e-scooter riders, 16% of e-bike riders, and 9.4% of bicycle riders. After adjustment, that level was not significantly associated with severe or critical injury, though the percentages may understate the share of riders who were intoxicated.
The researchers also found differences in where and how injuries occurred. Among e-scooter riders, 33% of injuries were classified as traffic-related, compared with 72% of bicycle injuries and 74% of e-bike injuries. Collisions accounted for 48% of e-scooter injuries, compared with 63% for bicycles and 59% for e-bikes.
"One of the clearest findings from our study was the association between wearing a helmet and having fewer serious injuries," Dr. Abbasi said. "My main takeaway from the study findings is to wear a helmet, pay attention to your surroundings, avoid riding under the influence of alcohol, and use protected lanes wherever possible."
The analysis included only injured adults treated at participating trauma centers. Because the database does not track how many trips people take on each device, the findings cannot establish which device has the highest risk of injury per trip. The data also lacked details such as riding speed and road conditions.
"There are real benefits to riding micromobility devices, and they can be a very healthy mode of transportation. But I would treat these devices like a car. You don't want to drive a car while inebriated or intoxicated. The same should be said for e-bikes, e-scooters, and bicycles," said Benjamin N. Breyer, MD, MAS, FACS, senior author of the study and a professor of urology at the University of California, San Francisco. "Riders can reduce their risk of injury by practicing safe riding habits, which includes following traffic laws, avoiding alcohol and drug use, and wearing a helmet."
Study co-authors are Philip W. Chu, MS; Marvin N. Carlisle, BS; Lynn Leng, MS; Nizar Hakam, MBBS; Alejandro Afanador-Jimenez, MD; Mikołaj Frankiewicz, MD; Ralph Wang, MD; and John M. Myrga, MD.
Disclosures: The authors have no relevant financial conflicts to disclose.
Citation: Abbasi B, Chu PW, Carlisle MN. Micromobility Injury Patterns and Resource Use in US Trauma Centers. Journal of the American College of Surgeons, 2026.