Is Music Industry Tone-Deaf on Gender Imbalance?

Men outnumber women by four to one of performers booked at live music venues, but a new study by the University of Portsmouth has found no evidence that audiences systematically prefer male singing voices.

Published in the Journal of Cultural Economics, the study used two experiments to investigate gender bias in music and explore what might lie behind the disparity in live performance opportunities.

Researchers first analysed 510 live music bookings across 15 UK cities over three months. They found that 410 performances featured male lead performers, compared with just 100 featuring women.

To investigate whether this imbalance reflected audience tastes, the researchers used artificial intelligence to create male and female vocal versions of otherwise identical musical tracks.

Participants were randomly assigned different versions and asked to rate the music on how much they liked it, how likely they thought others would enjoy it and how much they would be willing to pay to see the artist perform live.

The results found no preference for male over female vocals when participants assessed tracks individually. This challenged the suggestion that promoters and booking agents are simply responding to what audiences want when they book substantially more men than women.

To explore how gender perceptions might influence judgements of performers, the researchers also investigated how people picture musicians when they hear music without knowing anything about the artist.

Our findings suggest that the gender imbalance in live music cannot just be explained by audiences preferring male singers. When we controlled the music, we found no systematic preference for male over female vocals. This raises important questions about the assumptions being made by the people who decide who gets booked.

Dr Kate Whitman, Faculty of Business and Law at the University of Portsmouth

When participants listened to instrumental music and were asked to identify the gender of its creator, they were almost four times more likely to identify the performer as male rather than female.

This result suggests that men have become the default mental image of a credible musician, even when there is nothing in the music itself to indicate the performer's gender.

The researchers believe this perception could help feed the imbalance. When men dominate stages and line-ups, they become increasingly associated with musical credibility, potentially influencing the expectations of those responsible for booking performers.

Dr Kate Whitman , Faculty of Business and Law at the University of Portsmouth, said: "Our findings suggest that the gender imbalance in live music cannot just be explained by audiences preferring male singers. When we controlled the music, we found no systematic preference for male over female vocals. This raises important questions about the assumptions being made by the people who decide who gets booked."

However, the study also found that women tended to rate female performers less favourably than male performers. This was true even when the music was exactly the same, and participants were told it had been performed by either a man or a woman. This suggests that their judgements were influenced by the gender of the performer, rather than the music itself.

The researchers suggest this may reflect ingrained gender stereotypes and wider cultural attitudes that have historically led to women's creative work being undervalued.

One of the most striking findings is that people tend to picture a man when they think of a musician, even when they are listening to music that gives them no clues about the performer's gender. This points to a wider issue about who we instinctively regard as credible and deserving of recognition in the music industry.

Professor Joe Cox, School of Accounting, Economics and Finance, from the University of Portsmouth

Professor Joe Cox , School of Accounting, Economics and Finance , from the University of Portsmouth, said: "One of the most striking findings is that people tend to picture a man when they think of a musician, even when they are listening to music that gives them no clues about the performer's gender. This points to a wider issue about who we instinctively regard as credible and deserving of recognition in the music industry."

The researchers argue that the findings should prompt the live music industry to look more closely at its own booking practices and the assumptions behind them.

Although the experiments cannot establish exactly why individual performers are selected for gigs, they indicate that gendered perceptions of musical credibility could be contributing to the imbalance. If men are seen as the more typical or legitimate performers, those making booking decisions may unconsciously favour them, reinforcing a cycle in which women remain less visible.

The researchers recommend increasing the visibility of skilled female performers, introducing more transparent booking processes and regularly reviewing gender representation across live music line-ups.

More stories like this.

/Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.