Lonely Shoppers Show Less Compassion, Study Finds

Concordia University
A young woman sitting in a shopping cart

Chronically lonely people are less likely to buy products that benefit others, such as fair-trade or child-labour-free goods, according to a new study.

Researchers at Concordia and the University of the Fraser Valley ran four studies involving more than 1,400 participants across North America. Each person completed a standard loneliness questionnaire, then chose between ordinary products and versions that cost 15 to 20 per cent more but carried an ethical or environmental label. Items included toothpaste, chocolate bars, jackets and backpacks.

The lonelier participants reported that the more lonely they were, the less they favoured options with prosocial benefits (e.g., fair-trade and child-labour-free). However, their interest in environmentally friendly (e.g., recycled or organic) products held steady.

The researchers found that compassion plays an important role in this behaviour: chronic loneliness has long been linked to lower levels of compassion, which in turn reduces the appeal of products that help others. This fits an evolutionary theory that sees loneliness as a signal to protect oneself first.

The researchers also tested two interventions to counter this effect. In one experiment, a three-minute loving-kindness meditation, which involves wishing others well, erased the gap. They found similar results when participants were exposed to a fair-trade coffee ad that included the phrase, "Out of compassion for coffee farmers."

The findings offer practical lessons for businesses and organizations promoting ethical consumption. Compassion-focused messaging in advertisements, product descriptions, packaging and social media campaigns could help make socially responsible products more appealing. Brief meditation exercises could also be incorporated into public awareness initiatives, the researchers suggest.

Because prosocial actions are tied to greater well-being, the researchers believe this approach could also benefit the consumers themselves.

The article was published in Psychology and Marketing. The first author is Nasrin Yazdanian, PhD 24, now at the University of New Brunswick. Onur Bodur and Bianca Grohmann, both professors in the Department of Marketing at the John Molson School of Business, are co-authors.

Read the paper: "Chronic Loneliness Reduces Choice Likelihood of Products With Prosocial Attributes"

/Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.