Today, Mayor Zohran Kwame Mamdani announced that the New York City Law Department has filed a lawsuit seeking to hold persistently neglectful landlord Barry Singer accountable for years of dangerous conditions across 11 buildings in the Bronx and Brooklyn. The lawsuit seeks to compel repairs and recover more than $10 million in damages and penalties.
The filing marks the first time the City has used New York's False Claims Act to hold a building owner accountable for allegedly evading payments owed to the City for emergency repairs, pest control and judgments resulting from housing code violations. The lawsuit also alleges violations of the City's Nuisance Abatement Law and New York City Construction Codes. This new strategy was developed in collaboration with the legal advocacy group Housing Rights Initiative.
For decades, Singer has subjected tenants to dangerous conditions while ignoring hundreds of Building Code, Housing Maintenance Code and public safety violations across his properties. Through Fix the City, an initiative outlined in the administration's Block by Block housing plan and Rental Ripoff Report, the Mamdani administration is deploying escalating legal and enforcement tools to force the city's most chronically noncompliant landlords to comply with the law - or transfer their properties to responsible owners who will.
"We will not stand idly by while landlords neglect their buildings and leave tenants in dangerous living conditions for decades. When the same old tools fail to deliver results, we will use new strategies to hold noncompliant landlords accountable and win justice for tenants," said Mayor Mamdani. "Every New Yorker deserves a safe, well-maintained home, and we will use every tool at our disposal to make that a reality across the five boroughs."
"Every New Yorker deserves a safe, habitable place to live," said New York City Corporation Counsel Steven Banks. "Ignoring housing code violations and hiding behind shell companies has put both tenants and the public at risk. Using the False Claims Act, we have a powerful new tool to seek relief for tenants and hold landlords accountable for the public nuisances they have created in our communities."
"Through our 'Fix the City' initiative, the Mamdani Administration is using every tool at its disposal to hold noncompliant landlords accountable and stand with tenants demanding safe, livable homes. For years, Barry Singer has neglected his buildings while evading responsibility to his tenants. This new legal strategy brings us one step closer to securing the justice they deserve," said Leila Bozorg, Deputy Mayor for Housing and Planning.
"We're sending a clear message to chronically noncompliant landlords: subjecting tenants to hundreds of hazardous conditions is no longer an acceptable cost of doing business," said Dina Levy, Commissioner of the Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD). "By implementing aggressive, innovative tools-like our use of the False Claims Act-the Singer case establishes new methods for the City to advocate for tenants, protect existing affordable housing and hold bad actors accountable."
"We will not tolerate landlords who put New Yorkers at risk and deny them the safe, decent homes they have a right to live in. Under this administration, we are taking an aggressive approach to holding bad actors accountable, from strategies identified in the Mayor's Rental Ripoff initiative to new enforcement tactics like this lawsuit," said Buildings Commissioner Ahmed Tigani. "DOB has taken strong enforcement actions against Mr. Singer for violating city regulations including a criminal court summons, and hundreds of thousands of dollars in penalties. I thank our partners at HPD and the Law Department for using new and innovative tools to escalate this further by bringing forward this important case."
"In the Mamdani administration, City government is on tenants' side. Barry Singer has left his tenants in deplorable conditions for years. Now, we are taking action to protect our neighbors, recoup payments for repairs that the City has been forced to make because Singer wouldn't and send a clear message that this scale of noncompliance is unacceptable," said Cea Weaver, Director of the Mayor's Office to Protect Tenants.
Filed in Bronx County Supreme Court, the lawsuit details numerous serious violations and conditions constituting public nuisances, including unauthorized construction, severely cracked and deteriorating building facades, bulging and leaning walls and rusting fire escapes at risk of collapse.
According to the lawsuit, Singer has knowingly and improperly avoided paying the City more than $1.05 million, plus interest, in charges and judgments, including those for emergency repair work and pest control performed after the landlord failed to meet his basic responsibilities. The outstanding amounts also include court judgments stemming from proceedings brought after owners failed to correct violations issued by the Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD), as well as judgments from the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (OATH).
The City is asking the court to compel Singer to address the public nuisances and impose civil penalties of $1,000 per day for each violation of the Nuisance Abatement Law. The lawsuit also seeks correction of additional violations of the New York City Construction Codes and alleges that the defendants are liable for treble damages and civil penalties of up to $28,619 per violation under the New York False Claims Act.
Examples of the dangerous conditions at buildings included in the lawsuit include:
- 2500 Webb Avenue in the Bronx: The building has 456 violations, including 183 classified as "immediately hazardous." Conditions include a building facade described in the lawsuit as an "immediate hazard" with "potential to collapse," inadequate pedestrian protection and an obstructed fire escape.
- 3030 Heath Avenue in the Bronx: The building has been subject to a full vacate order since a four-alarm fire on Jan. 15, 2025. The owner has failed to comply with orders to repair the fire damage. Conditions include missing sections of the roof, water damage, missing windows, a partially collapsed loft area and problems with gas valves. The building has 261 violations, including 105 classified as "immediately hazardous."
Fix the City is a part of the Mamdani administration's broader effort to address New York's housing crisis by protecting tenants, preserving existing affordable housing and building new homes. Through Block by Block, the administration has set a goal of building 200,000 new affordable homes and preserving another 200,000 over the next decade. The plan is backed by a historic $22 billion investment in affordable housing capital over five years, alongside an ambitious land use agenda, reforms to streamline housing development and lower building operating costs, protections for homeowners, and investments in good jobs and worker safety.
"The City should be strongly commended for taking decisive action against landlords who violate critical laws enacted to protect the rights of all New Yorkers. This administration is demonstrating its unwavering commitment to enforcing these laws, holding violators accountable and using every legal tool at its disposal to secure justice," said Aaron Carr, Founder & Executive Director, Housing Rights Initiative.