Nearly Half of Australian Health Degrees Omit Sex Differences

Nearly half of Australia's accredited health and medical degrees do not mention sex or gender in a single course unit, according to a national review by the Centre for Sex and Gender Equity in Health and Medicine at The George Institute for Global Health, despite extensive evidence that many conditions present differently in women, men and gender diverse people.

The report notes that the research health care is built on has typically focused on adult males, which has led to delayed and missed diagnoses and adverse reactions to treatment in women and gender diverse people. The Australian Government's #EndGenderBias Survey found two thirds of women respondents reported gender bias or discrimination in hospital and general practice settings, including dismissal of pain and other symptoms. [1]

Medical students themselves report feeling the gap. In a survey by the Australian Medical Students' Association, submitted to the Victorian Government's inquiry into women's pain, around half of respondents said they felt inadequately trained to recognise and diagnose causes of women's pain.[2]

The review, funded by the Australian Government Department of Health, Disability and Ageing, examined 8,843 course units from 575 programs at 123 institutions across all 16 professions regulated under the National Registration and Accreditation Scheme. Only 1 in 10 course units mentioned sex or gender at all, and half of programs had no mention of sex or gender in any unit. In medicine, only 1 in 4 course units included mention of sex or gender, whereas in nursing and psychology, less than 1 in 20 course units did. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health and midwifery were the only professions where every accredited program included at least one mention of sex or gender.

No course unit mentioned sex or gender differences in cardiovascular disease, which is known to present differently in men and women. Of 89 course units with cardiovascular content, only three used sex or gender terms, and all were incidental descriptions in case studies, such as a 53-year-old woman requesting a repeat script. Just four course units discussed chronic pain in relation to sex and gender differences or women's health.

"

Decades of research shows that sex and gender fundamentally shape disease risk, symptoms, burden, and treatment outcomes, yet our review reveals that this knowledge is barely reaching the classroom When nearly half of accredited degrees never mention sex or gender in any unit, we risk sending graduates into practice unprepared to recognise how conditions differ between patients as a function of their sex or gender.

Where sex or gender was mentioned, it was often superficial or linked mainly to sexual and reproductive health. Medical course units referred to men's health just twice and terms for trans, non-binary and intersex people appeared very rarely or not at all..

Sex and gender affect every patient, so getting this right benefits everyone, not just women. Regulators and university leaders told us the most effective way to make consistent improvements to curricula is through accreditation standards that require sex and gender differences to be taught and we need systemic change rather than piecemeal progress.

By:

Professor Bronwyn Graham

Director of the Centre for Sex and Gender Equity in Health and Medicine at The George Institute for Global Health Australia and Professor at UNSW Sydney

The report sets out opportunities to improve how sex and gender are integrated into health and medical curricula, including creating a shared definition of good practice, developing guidance on how to integrate sex and gender into health and medical teaching, adding a standalone sex and gender section to NHMRC-endorsed clinical practice guidelines and embedding sex and gender into nationally consistent standards for safe and quality care.

The Centre for Sex & Gender Equity in Health & Medicine at The George Institute has also been commissioned by the Department of Health, Disability and Ageing to provide individualised feedback from the review to universities and deliver workshops for educators in Medicine, Nursing, and Psychology, on how to incorporate sex and gender considerations in curricula.

/Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.