Santa, Spongebob or Stegosaurus: real or not real?

Children as young as three can understand the difference between real figures and those that are make believe, according to University of Queensland research.

The research team examined how children evaluated different types of characters or figures relative to one another, as well as in comparison to real people.

Dr Nicole Nelson, from the UQ School of Psychology, said children’s judgments about what is real or not was fairly sophisticated.

“They aren’t just making simple ‘real’ versus ‘not real’ judgments, they are weighing the quality of the evidence they have for different figures,” Dr Nelson said.

“Children have seen dinosaur bones at museums, proving that dinosaurs once existed, and have found the milk and cookies gone on Christmas morning, showing that Santa has visited, and this evidence convinces them that both dinosaurs and Santa are real.

“When children don’t have strong evidence for or against something being real, like aliens or ghosts, they are able to say so and rate these figures as only moderately likely to be real, just as adults do.”

Australian children, aged two to 11-years-old, rated how real they considered 13 different figures ranging from real people like The Wiggles to more ambiguous identities like Santa Claus, ghosts, and aliens, as well as fictional characters like Spongebob Squarepants from the cartoon and Princess Elsa from the movie “Frozen”.

For comparison, 56 adults were also assessed.

The majority of children placed the 13 figures into four groups: ranked most highly as real were figures like dinosaurs and The Wiggles; the next-highest ranking went to cultural figures like Santa and the Tooth Fairy; followed by ambiguous figures like aliens, dragons and ghosts; and finally fictional characters like Peter Pan, Spongebob, and Elsa.

In comparison, adults and older children from seven years up, tended to group figures into three groups: real, not-real, and ambiguous.

The study, published in the journal PLOS ONE, was led by Dr Rohan Kapitány from Keele University while he was completing his PhD at UQ.

Dr Kapitány said rituals were a particularly potent signal for children when it came to accepting things like Santa Claus as real.

“Children tend to have a nuanced understanding of reality – more than many people would expect – and it is seen across a pantheon of figures who vary in their degree of ‘reality’ and cultural support,” he said.

“More research is now needed to understand how ritual participation and other factors lead children to understand what is real or not real in their world, particularly when they have no direct relevant experience.”

/Public Release. The material in this public release comes from the originating organization and may be of a point-in-time nature, edited for clarity, style and length. View in full here.