ANN ARBOR—University of Michigan researchers have developed a better way to understand why earthquakes occur and what size they might be.
Currently, models that predict earthquakes only account for slipping that occurs along a main fault, activity that usually generates large earthquakes. Instead, the U-M researchers have built a model that considers not only the main fault action, but also the activity of rocks that lie adjacent to the fault and become damaged during earthquake events.
By considering both the fault and outlying rocks, the researchers' model is able to explain earthquake activity, including why small earthquakes occur much more frequently than larger earthquakes.
"If we can better understand the small earthquakes, we can understand the link between earthquakes of different sizes. It has implications for the mechanism of large earthquakes," said Peng Zhai , who built the model during his doctoral work at U-M. "To better understand and forecast earthquakes, we need to fully understand the stress conditions on the fault and the off-fault damage."
Their study, supported by the U.S. National Science Foundation, is published in Science Advances.
To build the model, the researchers included the full cycle of an earthquake, including how stress builds up in the fault zone, the earthquake "nucleation"—or the moment the fault starts to slip—and the earthquake rupture. They also considered how damaged rock would settle and heal after an earthquake. Additionally, the model simulates seismic activity that occurs on time scales that range from seconds to centuries.
"If you look at something like the San Andreas Fault from the air, you can see that the fault is actually a whole field of rocks that have fractures and damage that extend out hundreds of meters or kilometers from the main fault," said senior author Yihe Huang , professor of earth and environmental sciences. "Even though earthquakes occur on that main fault plane, you actually have a lot of damage going on close to that fault. We can see that from the surface all the time, but we rarely consider that in the models because that would introduce another complexity you have to solve."
Zhai says their holistic model can explain why smaller earthquakes occur much more frequently. The model can also explain why earthquakes of different sizes release about the same amount of stress: larger earthquakes may rupture a larger fault area, but the stress relieved over the whole ruptured area is about the same as a smaller earthquake. Finally, the model shows that the energy needed for an earthquake to rupture a unit fault area increases with the size of the earthquake. For the first time, the three general features of earthquakes can be explained within a unified physical framework.
"One interesting point is that these results are consistent with a long-standing hypothesis called the weak-fault zone hypothesis. Our results suggest that the fault zone strength can be very low, so that we have multiscale seismicity, or both large and small earthquakes," said Zhai, now a postdoctoral researcher at Utah State University.
Huang says the weak zone hypothesis might also explain why there are more smaller earthquakes. Because the rocks surrounding the fault zone deform so easily, they actually absorb energy from the main rupture, deadening the force of a larger earthquake and instead producing a smaller one. But this may also help generate a larger earthquake down the line.
"We have to incorporate these fault zone effects into our earthquake models to better understand earthquakes and capture more realistic scenarios," Zhai said. "The reason traditional earthquake models only consider elastic deformation of the fault zone is because it's more simple. It's easier to compute. But if you introduce inelastic deformation, or the energy into the surrounding rocks, it's more realistic."
Huang says the study wouldn't have been possible without her NSF Career grant.
"This is the result of years of effort and multiple researchers, to be able to construct this final model that can capture very interesting phenomena," she said.