Why Mobile Shopping Can Make You Second-Guess Purchase

You find the product you want on your phone. You compare prices, read reviews and weigh the options. Then, just before tapping "Buy," you hesitate: Maybe I should look at this again on my computer.

New research by University of Miami Business School professors Michael Tsiros and Claudia Townsend suggests there may be a psychological explanation. Smartphones can make consumers feel as though they haven't thought a decision through, even when their decision-making hasn't suffered.

"We discovered that the device people use to shop can influence not only what they buy, but also how confident they feel about their decisions," said Tsiros, marketing professor and Centennial Endowed Chair. "Sometimes what prevents us from buying something is not a lack of information or a poor decision, but the feeling that we haven't thought about it enough."

Consumers increasingly use smartphones to browse and compare products but remain less likely to complete purchases on phones than on computers, a phenomenon researchers call the "mobile conversion gap."

In the study published in the Journal of Marketing, Tsiros, Townsend and Vincentia Yuen of City University of Hong Kong examined the psychology behind that gap through a pilot study, nine controlled experiments, an analysis of real-world sales data and a field experiment.

They found that using a smartphone can lower consumers' sense of how thoroughly they have thought about a decision, which can reduce their confidence and make them less likely to complete a purchase.

Smaller screens may seem less suited to comparing information. People also tend to associate computers with work and serious tasks, and smartphones with quick interactions and entertainment. Because phones are often used in short bursts, those habits may reinforce an association with less deliberate thinking.

"The interesting point is that our perceptions are influenced not just by what a device allows us to do, but by how we've become accustomed to using it," Tsiros said.

In the experiments, participants evaluated products on either a smartphone or a computer. Researchers measured how good participants expected their decisions to be and how well they actually performed on tasks that required careful evaluation of product information.

Smartphone users expected their decisions to be worse, but they performed just as well.

That disconnect can shape behavior. Consumers who believe a smartphone decision is less thoughtful may postpone a purchase, switch to a computer or abandon the purchase altogether. The effect was weaker when a decision seemed to require little thought, such as buying a familiar or routine product.

Can businesses reduce the hesitation?

In one field experiment, adding the phrase "No thought required!" to a Facebook ad for a retailer's newsletter made smartphone users about 44 percent more likely to click through to the sign-up page. The phrase did not change the behavior of computer users.

In sales data from an online gift retailer, smartphone shoppers were less likely to buy than computer shoppers. But when the retailer offered a concierge service that selected the gift for them, that gap shrank by more than half.

"It really says that consumers don't trust themselves to complete tasks on a smartphone if they think it involves a great deal of thought," said Townsend, marketing professor. "By assuring them that not a lot of thought is required, or that the retailer will do some of the thinking on their behalf, one can motivate consumers to act instead of hesitating on a smartphone."

For businesses, the researchers say, making mobile shopping fast and convenient may not be enough. Clear comparisons, concise summaries and tools that help consumers evaluate choices could also build confidence.

For consumers, the lesson is not to mistake the feeling of having thought less carefully for evidence that they actually have.

The research centers on consumer decisions, but Tsiros sees a larger question in the findings.

"Technology does not just change how we make decisions," he said. "It can also change how we feel about the decisions we make, and sometimes that feeling can be strong enough to change our behavior."

/Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.