As online journals, preprint servers and AI-driven databases continue to proliferate, it's easy to view books as relics of the past. However, especially in an academic field like microbiology, books remain indispensable as they offer not only information, but also structure, context and a type of durability that is increasingly rare in our digital world.
This isn't a nostalgic defense of print media, but rather a recognition that, despite the importance and utility of digital information products, books continue to serve a distinct and irreplaceable role.
Structured Knowledge Contextualizes Data
As professionals, we understand that science requires more than the memorization of facts; it also requires conceptual fluency across a wide range of interconnected subjects. For example, microbiology, as a discipline, encompasses a complex understanding of genetics, physiology, ecology, immunology, molecular biology and more. While individually published research articles and online resources may quickly provide specific facts and findings, they often, by nature, lack some of the foundational, structural and theoretical underpinnings needed to meaningfully integrate details into the broader body of knowledge.
Scholarly books (including textbooks, reference manuals and monographs) are often organized in a systematic way, building ideas step-by-step, connecting disciplines and providing a level of commentary, integration and synthesis that can be difficult to replicate in shorter form pieces. For graduate students and researchers, these texts are especially useful in developing a fuller understanding of complex topics before engaging with primary literature.
Quality Control and Editorial Rigor
The increasing accessibility of scientific information online has certainly been a boon for scientific progress. However, it comes with certain trade-offs, including that not everything is properly vetted. While true scholarly journals uphold rigorous peer review processes, other types of informal scientific content-such as blogs, social media posts, predatory journal publications and even some preprints-introduce a wider margin for error and can lead to the (intentional or unintentional) proliferation of scientific misinformation.
Books, especially those from established scholarly publishers, typically undergo extensive editorial review processes by experts working in the field. This matters. When discussing topics like the treatment of clinical infections, molecular diagnostics or biosafety procedures, the use of incorrect information can have serious effects on human health and well-being. ASM's long-standing reference works, (e.g., the Manual of Clinical Microbiology [now in its 13th edition], the Manual of Molecular and Clinical Laboratory Immunology [now in its ninth edition] and Clinical Microbiology Procedures Handbook [now in its fifth edition]) remain cornerstone references, not just because of their authoritative history, but also because their experienced, trusted editorial teams ensure topical relevance and accuracy.
Contextualizing the Present Through the Past
Scientific knowledge is cumulative, but not necessarily linear, and books offer the opportunity to illustrate that historical trajectory. Books also provide a platform to feature the individuals involved in scientific progress, highlighting the often-invisible lives behind the science, and humanizing the enterprise as a whole.
For example, works like Magic Bullets, Miracle Drugs, and Microbiologists and Germ Theory provide narratives of conceptual development-something that is often absent in other scientific publications, and which may be overlooked from our modern point of view. For researchers trying to understand why certain dogmas persist, or where research gaps exist, these historical and philosophical perspectives are both informative and useful.
Teaching, Mentorship and Intellectual Continuity
In academic settings, books still play a large role in how microbiology is taught. Textbooks and other reference books provide students at all levels with a solid base of knowledge upon which to build.
Books also play an important role in mentorship. Whether it's an instructor recommending a foundational text to a new student to immerse themselves in a field of research or a lab director handing down an annotated copy of a favorite diagnostic guide to a new tech, books foster intellectual continuity within labs and across generations of microbiologists.
Books Complement Digital Resources
This is not to say that digital resources don't have value. Online journals, tools like PubMed and the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) databases and preprint archives have transformed science. But effective use of these tools often requires a foundational understanding that books are uniquely suited to provide.
For instance, using NCBI's BLAST tool effectively requires more than just technical proficiency-a strong understanding of sequence homology, evolutionary concepts and functional annotation are also needed to make the most of the tool. A text like the Manual of Molecular Microbiology: Fundamentals and Applications contextualizes methodologies and procedures, often explaining the rationale, limitations and interpretative frameworks behind each method.
Books and digital tools should be viewed as complementary. A good book can sharpen one's ability to critically evaluate a dataset, design an experiment or interpret literature findings.
Durability in a Rapidly Changing Landscape
The pace of microbiological research continues to accelerate, and in this rapidly changing landscape stable, coherent frameworks of knowledge remain vitally important. Books don't change with every new preprint, news article or social media post. They can't be wiped away with the click of a button. They encourage the type of long-form, focused thinking that's increasingly rare in our modern culture.
Of course, books are not perfect resources. They can be outdated, limited in scope, skewed by the perceptions of their editorial teams and sometimes inaccessible due to cost or availability. But the best scientific books don't aim to be standalone tomes that replace the rest of the scientific literature-instead they aim to equip readers to engage with it more effectively.
The Bottom Line
Books help us think more clearly, teach more effectively and engage more critically with the increasingly fast-paced world of modern science.
As we embrace new platforms and technologies, it's worth remembering that books remain essential-not despite their slowness and permanence, but because of it. In a field defined by complexity and change, the clarity and depth that books offer is not just useful-it's necessary.
ASM Press publishes textbooks, reference manuals, professional resources and general interest titles across the breadth of the microbial sciences.
Do you have a book idea that would contribute to the field of microbiology?
