
During the record-breaking Pacific Northwest heat dome in 2021, a mussel's life depended on its size and location on the shoreline at Cattle Point on San Juan Island.
The carpet of mussels covering the rocky promontory vary in size. Smaller mussels cluster higher up the shore while the beefier ones bathe 10 to 15 feet lower.
A new University of Washington study examined patterns of mussel mortality following the heat wave, which brought 100-degree weather to a region that's accustomed to highs in the mid-70s. Many marine organisms withered in the midday sun, but the Cattle Point mussels fared relatively well. Researchers developed a physics-based model to predict survival from mass and heat transfer data. In this case, it was bad to be average.
"We found this survival pattern that favored small mussels high on the shore and large mussels lower on the shore," said lead author Jack Litle, who recently completed his doctoral studies in Biology.
This study, conducted at the UW's Friday Harbor Laboratories and published Nov. 18 in Proceedings of the Royal Society B, looked exclusively at mussels, but the model can also be applied to other shellfish elsewhere.

The Cattle Point mussels are well studied. Before the heat wave, researchers had been collecting temperature data using biomimetic "robomussels" for decades. Former UW graduate student Brian Helmuth developed the approach and the study's lead author Emily Carrington has been managing the robomussels for the past 10 years.
Robomussels are fake mussels designed to mimic the size, shape, color and thermal properties of real mussels. A small thermometer encased in black epoxy provides a continuous record of the temperatures experienced by mussels living nearby.
Litle approached Carrington, a professor of biology at UW and his advisor, about studying the impact of extreme heat on mussels. She suggested Cattle Point, where the robomussels were already distributed.
Carrington also suggested that they look at size as well as survival, thinking that older, often larger mussels might tolerate heat better than young ones. They returned to the site one week, two weeks and three weeks after the onset of the heat wave to count the "freshly dead" mussels, which pop wide open like they've just been steamed in a pot.
After analyzing the data, the results seemed underwhelming at first. Overall mortality was low, and the size pattern was different than expected. With more small mussels up high, they anticipated more dead small mussels, and more dead large ones down low. Instead, they observed the opposite - the mussels that died up high were bigger than average, and those that died down low were smaller.

"I can just so clearly remember where Jack and I were standing when the first data graphs popped on the screen - it was one of those rare ''aha moments," Carrington said. "We immediately began thinking about how rates of heating depend on body size. Jack got to work developing the heat budget model to show how the temperature effects of body size change with habitat."
Because of the tides, mussels higher up on the shore are exposed to sunlight for nearly twice as long as those lower down. Mussels can cool off two ways: by "sweating" out seawater, or from the wind. Larger mussels retain more seawater than smaller ones, prolonging the window for evaporative cooling. Smaller mussels have a greater surface area to volume ratio, making them more efficient wind coolers.
The mussels that died high on the shore likely ran out of water for evaporative cooling and were too big for efficient wind cooling. Those that died lower down were considered too small to hold enough water for extended evaporative cooling.
Because the model is physics based, it applied to other coastal areas that experience tides, and could benefit the shellfish industry. Oyster growers keep oysters low on the shore to fatten up before moving them up higher to strengthen their shells. This study could tell them how big the shells can get before the risk of heat mortality rises.
In the future, a similar approach could provide insight into other evaporative coolers too.
"Evaporative cooling is not just a shellfish thing - amphibians, birds and mammals do something very similar," Litle said. "The biology is different, but the same physical principles apply. This same sort of thinking could be extended to different taxonomic groups."
Co-authors include Robin Fales of Soka University of America and Kindall Murie of Stanford University, both former doctoral students in the Carrington lab.
This research was funded by the U.S. National Science Foundation, University of Washington Friday Harbor Laboratories W.T. Edmonson Award, University of Washington Friday Harbor Laboratories Charles Lambert Memorial Endowment Award, University of Washington Friday Harbor Laboratories Riddiford-Truman Award, and University of Washington Friday Harbor Laboratories Richard R. and Megumi F. Strathmann Endowed Fellowship.