Ecosystems can only buffer the impacts of climate change and humans for so long until an ecological turning point is reached, a new study on Aotearoa New Zealand's extinct mātuhituhi – bush wren has highlighted.
The study, an international collaboration between the University of Otago – Ōtākou Whakaihu Waka, Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa, the UK's Natural History Museum, and the Australian Museum, used ancient DNA to reconstruct the evolutionary history of the birds, which only died out in the 1970s within living memory.
Lead author Dr Alex Verry, who conducted the study as part of his PhD research at Otago, says the analysis showed bush wren diverged from their closest relatives – the pīwauwau rock wren and extinct stout-legged wren – 6.6 million years ago, as the Southern Alps rose up and created new habitats.
"North and South Island bush wren then diverged 2.6 million years ago as the marine sea straits that separated the North and South Islands narrowed.
"Importantly, in the South Island there was a long period of evolutionary stability until 470,000 to 330,000 years ago when South Island bush wren simultaneously diverged into multiple subspecies as they retreated to different refugia across the island after the Ice Ages became significantly longer and harsher.
"The Ice Ages began about 2.6 million years ago, so this gives you an idea about the levels of environmental change bush wren could endure before they reached a tipping point and had to respond or go extinct," he says.
Published in the international journal Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution, the study also analysed the birds' plumage.
Senior author Associate Professor Nic Rawlence, of the Department of Zoology, says the specimens were genetically sexed to tease apart variation in the colour of their plumage.
"The work revolutionised our basic understanding of these birds.
"It's generally assumed we know more about the evolution of animals that went extinct recently, compared to those that went extinct hundreds or thousands of years ago. The mātuhituhi only went extinct in the mid-1970s, when their last stronghold on Big South Cape Island off the southern tip of Rakiura Stewart Island was invaded by rats. It's extinction fundamentally changed conservation practice worldwide for endangered species on islands.
"However, scientists know very little about these enigmatic birds, with phrases like 'poorly known' and 'virtually unknown' commonly used to describe them.
"Our plumage analysis showed they have high levels of colour variation between males and females, and between subspecies. This was not achievable without genetic sexing, given historic confusion amongst scientists regarding the recorded sex and collection locality of specimens," Associate Professor Rawlence says.
The work also revealed a new subspecies of bush wren, hidden in plain sight in museum collections since the 19th Century.
"We found one from the central and northern South Island which was distinct – both genetically and plumage-wise – from the other North Island, Fiordland, and Stead's bush wrens.
"We named this new wren Xenicus longipes perditus, with perditus being Latin for lost – as in lost to extinction. The common name is Tōtaranui bush wren, named after the te reo name for Queen Charlotte Sound," he says.
Dr Verry says bush wren were forest specialists and relied on these ecosystems to provide suitable habitat.
"This makes them a good proxy for how forests have responded to past climate change and human impact. Our study has highlighted how ecosystems can protect species against these impacts, but only up to a point.
"It is up to us to determine whether we are going to conserve ecosystems and increase climate resilience before our taonga (treasured) species reach this tipping point or whether we are going to pick up the pieces of what's left after they've gone."
Funding:
Funding was provided by the Royal Society Te Apārangi Marsden Fund, Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa, and the University of Otago.
Publication:
Evolutionary history of Aotearoa New Zealand's extinct mātuhituhi | bush wren
Alexander J.F. Verry, Alan J.D. Tennyson, Jana R. Wold, Alexander L. Bond, Jacqueline M.T. Nguyen, Nicolas J. Rawlence
Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1055790326002113