In 1965, scientists Robert Burns Woodward and Roald Hoffmann devised a set of rules to predict the outcome of electrocyclic reactions, an important class of reactions in organic chemistry. The Woodward-Hoffmann rules explain why certain compounds fail to form while others are easily produced and predict how the atoms will be arranged in products formed during ring-opening reactions. They provided the foundation for many chemical theories in the field and earned Roald Hoffmann the Nobel Prize in chemistry in 1981.
More than half a century after their formulation, scientists at the Department of Energy’s SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory have captured how a process predicted by these rules unfolds using MeV-UED, the lab’s ultrafast “electron camera.” The results, published last week in Science, are the first to directly confirm these rules and could lead to a better understanding of reactions with vital roles in chemistry and biology.
“Two generations of chemists have learned about the Woodward-Hoffmann rules, and there are a lot of conceptual ideas that originated from them,” said SLAC scientist Thomas Wolf, who led the study. “But until now, these were all basically predictions. Nobody had ever seen them unfold in real time. In our study, we found a way to image the reaction and observe how the molecule transforms into the product as predicted by these rules, directly confirming that they really work.”
Opening the ring
Ring-shaped molecules play key roles in many biological and chemical processes that are driven by the formation and breaking of chemical bonds. The researchers used MeV-UED to make a high-definition “movie” of ring-shaped gas molecules breaking open in response to light. Using a technique called ultrafast electron diffraction (UED), the researchers sent an electron beam with high energy, measured in millions of electronvolts (MeV), through a sample – to precisely measure distances between pairs of atoms. Taking snapshots of these distances at different intervals after an initial laser flash and tracking how they change, allows scientists to create a stop-motion movie of the light-induced atomic rearrangements in the sample.
Their investigation is the first to exploit the sensitivity of MeV-UED to study conformers, structures of the same molecule with slightly different shape that are integral in chemistry but are difficult to study using existing experimental methods.
The Woodward-Hoffmann rules predict different conformers of the study’s sample, α-phellandrene, will yield different products from the ring opening reaction. Using MeV UED, the researchers were able to follow in real time how a specific conformer of α-phellandrene turned into the reaction product predicted by the Woodward-Hoffmann rules, settling a longstanding debate about the exact motion by which the molecule’s ring opened.
“This is the first time that anybody has ever directly observed this motion,” Wolf says. “We demonstrate that the molecules open exclusively in the way predicted by the Woodward-Hoffmann rules.”