Should We Save Every Old Building?

A close-up photograph of a person outdoors, wearing a scarf and jacket, with a blurred natural background. Photo.
RAISING QUESTIONS: Is it better to build replicas of historic buildings than to preserve them as they stand? There are certainly good reasons to ask the question, according to UiO researcher Anne-Sofie Hjemdahl. Photo: Telemarksforsking

When you visit one of Norway's open-air museums, you can experience a piece of old Norway: log-built timber houses, farmsteads and farm complexes, often situated in a historic cultural landscape.

For a long time, the idea has been to preserve the old. These buildings are so valuable that we call them "cultural heritage". But what about the smell that sometimes greets you when you enter a preserved house?

"The research we have carried out has made the whole heritage project wobble a little," says Anne-Sofie Hjemdahl, a cultural historian at the University of Oslo (UiO).

This is because cultural heritage carries a toxic industrial legacy.

"Throughout the twentieth century, sometimes considerable quantities of toxic chemicals were used in the conservation of old buildings. This is an industrial legacy that we in Norway have only recently begun to recognise. But where do we go from here? We do not really know," Hjemdahl says.

The Norwegian Museum of Cultural History had to rethink its plans

She has worked closely with Terje Planke, senior curator at the Norwegian Museum of Cultural History in Oslo. He recently led the construction of a traditional crafts centre at the museum. They wanted to use an old barn as a workshop for demonstrating traditional crafts.

But then they noticed the smell of railway sleepers in the building. Measurements revealed high levels of toxic substances, confirming the use of creosote, a carcinogenic agent previously used to prevent rot, fungal growth and insect infestations in railway sleepers and buildings.

"The levels of various toxic substances inside were so high that we did not want to take the risk involved in spending extended periods there. So, after discussing it with those funding the project, we decided to construct a new building instead," says Planke, who also holds a part-time professorship at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU).

The barn is still standing, but it is now used for storage.

A red barn surrounded by grass and trees. Photo.
FULL OF CREOSOTE: This barn at the Norwegian Museum of Cultural History was intended for demonstrating traditional craft knowledge, but museum staff noticed the smell of creosote. It was particularly strong on hot summer days. Photo: Terje Planke

"It is as though we could freeze time"

This is the kind of assessment that many people will have to make in the years ahead. Across Norway, there are old buildings - including stave churches - where prolonged stays may pose a health risk. This emerged in a report from the Directorate for Cultural Heritage earlier in 2026, to which Hjemdahl and Planke were among the contributors.

The pilot study found high levels of hazardous chemicals in nine older buildings in different parts of Norway, including Urnes Stave Church in Sogn.

Previously, Hjemdahl and her colleagues had investigated conditions at a small number of museums, including Gamle Hvam Museum in Akershus and Maihaugen in Lillehammer.

Creosote and several other substances were banned in the 1980s. However, they persist for a long time. In addition, new substances have been introduced - and we do not know the effects of several of them, particularly when they are mixed, according to Hjemdahl.

The situation raises a number of questions: What do we do with the buildings that remain? What exactly are we preserving when a medieval house is full of creosote, which is flammable, harmful to health and a source of environmental pollution?

"The idea that we should preserve things as they are, far into the future, is part of a modernist project. It is as though we could freeze time. It is an optimistic and noble idea, but it comes with certain costs," Hjemdahl says.

Greater acceptance of change may be unavoidable

There are also ethical questions concerning the animals that live in the timber, she points out. The house longhorn beetle, a wood-eating beetle that can cause extensive damage to timber buildings, is for example listed as threatened on Norway's Red List.

"This creates some interesting tensions. Who has a right to our cultural heritage? When an insect enters an eighteenth-century building, should we do everything we can to drive it out? Or should we allow insects to 'use' the building too?"

Both Planke and Hjemdahl believe that more knowledge is needed: Which buildings are affected, and how high are the levels of toxic substances? This may also apply to old houses outside museums, they point out.

A person wearing a safety helmet and a patterned woollen jumper stands inside a building under restoration, surrounded by timber walls and stacks of wooden blocks. Photo.
CALLS FOR A SURVEY: Professional communities have long buried their heads in the sand, according to senior curator Terje Planke at the Norwegian Museum of Cultural History. Norway now needs a comprehensive survey of museum buildings, followed by effective measures, he believes. Photo: Norwegian Museum of Cultural History

Planke says that there was not much reflection on these issues when the substances were banned:

"Perhaps we buried our heads in the sand. But now we have raised them. We need to test for toxic substances, and we need to protect museum staff, visitors and nature, as well as the objects themselves," he says.

The two researchers also believe that we need to think more deeply about what preservation means. Today, building conservation can also involve providing buildings with other forms of care, such as fitting new gutters, Planke points out.

Some museums, including the Norwegian Industrial Workers Museum, are trying to manage insects without hazardous chemicals. Instead, they monitor insect activity.

Hjemdahl puts it this way:

"The bureaucracy surrounding this is a heavy battleship to turn around, but I think reflection on preservation - and greater acceptance of change - will force its way through."

Perhaps some things should be allowed to decay

She asks: Can we accept that parts of buildings are, in some cases, replaced with types of wood that insects do not want to inhabit? Or might we imagine giving certain houses over to the house longhorn beetle?

According to Hjemdahl, heritage research is now discussing "curated decay": the idea that we can gain a different kind of knowledge, and different memories, when things are allowed to deteriorate.

"Perhaps museum visitors could, for example, wear headphones that allow them to listen to the clicking sounds made by house longhorn beetles in the timber. In that way, cultural history museums could convey more than just human history."

Moreover, over the past twenty years, traditional craft knowledge has received greater attention both from the Directorate for Cultural Heritage and from museums across Norway.

"Knowledge of how to build a house using traditional methods may be at least as important as spending vast resources trying to freeze time," says Hjemdahl.

References

/University of Oslo Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.