Popular GLP-1 drugs help many people drop tremendous amounts of weight, but the drugs fail to provide a key improvement in heart and lung function essential for long-term good health, University of Virginia experts warn in a new paper.
The researchers emphasize that weight loss associated with GLP-1 drugs has many clear health benefits for people with obesity, type 2 diabetes and heart failure, including improving blood-sugar control, short-term cardiorenal benefits and improvements in survival outcomes. But doctors may need to consider recommending exercise programs or develop other approaches, such as nutrition supplements or complementary medications, to help GLP-1 patients get the full cardiorespiratory benefits of substantial weight loss over the long-run, the researchers say.
"Some patients literally told me that they felt that they were losing muscle or muscle was slipping away from them while they were on these medications," said researcher Zhenqi Liu, MD, Professor of Medicine and James M. Moss Professor of Diabetes at the University of Virginia School of Medicine and former chief of UVA Health's Division of Endocrinology and Metabolism. "This is a serious concern. Muscle, especially axial muscle, is essential for posture, physical function and overall well-being. Losing lean body mass can increase the risk of cardiovascular disease, all-cause mortality and diminished quality of life. We need to make sure that patients prescribed these medications aren't already at risk for malnutrition or low muscle mass."
About GLP-1 Drugs
While GLP-1 drugs help people lose fat, this comes with loss of fat-free mass, of which muscle makes up 40% to 50%. In fact, fat-free mass lost accounts for 25-40% of the total pounds lost, while age-related declines in fat-free mass are only 8% per decade.
Liu and his collaborators, graduate student Nathan R. Weeldreyer and Siddhartha S. Angadi, PhD, Associate Professor of Kinesiology at UVA's School of Education and Human Development, wanted to better understand the potential long-term consequences of this muscle loss, so they reviewed available data on the drugs' effects on cardiorespiratory fitness, or CRF.
CRF (or VO2max) is a measure of how well the body can use oxygen during exercise. It is a handy way for doctors to assess how well the heart, lungs, muscle and blood vessels work together, and it is used to predict all-cause and cardiovascular mortality (risk of death).
Patients with obesity often have low CRF. In some cases, this is because the person lacks muscle mass; in others, a person may have enough muscle, but the quality of that muscle is compromised by fat that has penetrated it.
"Cardiorespiratory fitness is a potent predictor of all-cause and cardiovascular mortality risk across a range of populations, including obesity, diabetes and heart failure," said Angadi, a cardiovascular exercise physiologist with UVA's Department of Kinesiology. "In a recent study by our group that examined mortality outcomes from almost 400,000 individuals across the world, we found that CRF was far superior to overweight or obesity status for predicting the risk of death. In fact, once CRF was factored in, body weight failed to predict the risk of mortality. This is why it's so important to understand the effects of this new class of drugs on it."
In their review of the available medical literature, the researchers found that GLP-1 drugs improve certain measures of heart function, yet those improvements don't translate into significant improvements in VO2max.
Some small studies, they note, have suggested that exercise can help improve VO2max for patients taking GLP-1 drugs, but these had poor controls and larger, well-designed studies are needed to bear that out.
Ensuring Healthy Weight Loss
The researchers ultimately conclude that GLP-1 drugs "significantly reduce body weight and adiposity, along with a substantial FFM [fat-free mass] loss, but with no clear evidence of CRF enhancement." They remain concerned that this could take a toll on patients' metabolic health, healthspan/frailty and overall longevity. They are urging additional research to better understand the effects of the drugs and ensure patients get the best possible outcomes.
They note, however, that there are promising signs that we may be able to develop medications to help, such as a monoclonal antibody already in the pipeline that may be able to offset lean-muscle loss.
"This is an area of active research, and we are hopeful that better solutions are coming soon," Liu said. "But for now it is important that patients prescribed GLP-1 drugs have conversations with their healthcare providers about strategies to preserve muscle mass. The American Diabetes Association recommends screening for malnutrition and low muscle mass risk before starting these medications and promoting adequate protein intake and regular exercise throughout treatment."
"Finally," Angadi added, "exercise training during GLP1 therapy remains to be assessed in its ability to preserve or improve VO2max during GLP1 therapy."
Findings Published
The researchers have published their findings in JCEM, the Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism . The work was supported by the National Institutes of Health, grants R01DK124344 and R01DK125330.
The UVA researchers have no financial interest in the work.
To keep up with the latest medical research news from UVA, subscribe to the Making of Medicine blog at http://makingofmedicine.virginia.edu .
