Key Takeaways
- A study of all 3,144 U.S. counties found that 1,430 counties (45%), home to 26.6 million residents, had no in-county general surgeon, surgical oncologist, or colorectal surgeon. Of those residents, 13.5 million lived in metropolitan counties.
- Colorectal cancer mortality was about 6% higher in surgical deserts than in counties with local surgical access, after adjustment for socioeconomic factors, rurality, region and incidence.
- Surgical desert counties had higher rate of deaths for colorectal, pancreatic, and hepatobiliary cancers and later-stage diagnosis for pancreatic, hepatobiliary, gastric, and esophageal cancers.
CHICAGO – Nearly half of U.S. counties have no surgeon who performs gastrointestinal or hepatopancreatobiliary (liver, pancreas, gallbladder and bile ducts) cancer operations, and residents of those counties have higher death rates from several of those cancers even after accounting for socioeconomic factors and rurality, according to a study published in the Journal of the American College of Surgeons .
The cross-sectional ecological study linked the 2025 CMS Doctors and Clinicians file with NCI/CDC State Cancer Profiles, the Area Deprivation Index, 2023 Rural-Urban Continuum Codes and 2020 Census populations across all 3,144 U.S. counties, representing 331 million residents. A gastrointestinal and hepatopancreatobiliary (GI/HPB) surgical desert was defined as a county with no in-county general surgeon, surgical oncologist, or colorectal surgeon. The findings build on the College's 2026 surgical workforce map, which found that 15 million Americans live in a county with no general surgeon.
Overall, 1,430 counties (45%), encompassing 26.6 million residents, were surgical deserts. Surgical desert counties were smaller, more deprived and less often metropolitan, but 13.5 million affected residents lived in metropolitan counties. Surgical desert counties were also less likely to have a hospital (55% vs. 95% of surgeon-present counties).
Colorectal cancer mortality was about 28% higher in surgical deserts before adjustment and remained about 6% higher after adjusting for deprivation, rurality, region and incidence. Adjusted mortality was also higher for pancreatic cancer and for cancers of the liver, gallbladder and bile ducts. The model-predicted adjusted colorectal cancer mortality was 13.6 per 100,000 in desert counties versus 12.9 in surgeon-present counties, a relative difference of 5.8%.
The findings are personal for senior author Hassan Aziz, MD, FACS, a transplant and hepatobiliary surgeon and clinical assistant professor of surgery at University of Iowa Healthcare. He sees patients who travel hours for cancer and transplant care, some arriving with advanced disease that could have been curable earlier. He also noticed a pattern of ruptured liver cancer among patients who had cirrhosis but were never told to get surveillance ultrasounds.
"Once you have been diagnosed with cirrhosis , you should get ultrasounds to surveil for tumors," Dr. Aziz said. "To me, that started becoming a marker that nobody even told them they have cirrhosis, nobody told them they have cancer. These patients could have had curative transplant or surgery, but now the tumor has ruptured and spilled everywhere, and curing is no longer an option."
Among counties that already had a surgeon, surgeon density was not associated with colorectal cancer mortality, and mortality was flat across quartiles of density.
"That may be because there were other surrogates of care, such as a primary care physician," Dr. Aziz said. "Just having a surgeon may not lead to good outcomes alone. We need a team—primary care physicians, hepatologists, and people who can get you screened."
To separate detection from treatment, the researchers analyzed late-stage diagnosis and case fatality. Surgical deserts had higher case fatality for colorectal (1.3%), pancreatic (3.4%) and hepatobiliary (3.8%) cancers, consistent with worse survival after diagnosis. Excess late-stage diagnosis was confined to cancers whose detection depends on specialist infrastructure: pancreatic (1.9%), hepatobiliary (4.6%), gastric (5.8%) and esophageal (3.3%). For screen-detected colorectal cancer, stage distribution was unaffected by surgical desert status, and guideline-concordant colorectal cancer screening was not lower in surgical deserts.
"Colorectal cancer has very strict, established screening pathways, while other GI cancers often do not have specialized diagnostic evaluations," Dr. Aziz said. "That distinction suggests improving access to diagnosis and improving access to treatment may require different strategies for different cancers."
The authors outline several policy directions, including strengthening surgical workforce recruitment and retention, building better regional referral networks and care coordination between smaller hospitals and major cancer centers, and expanding satellite hospitals, mobile screening centers and telemedicine, while acknowledging that telemedicine can't reach older, less tech-savvy patients or those struggling with internet access. Dr. Aziz emphasized that socioeconomic deprivation accounts for a substantial part of the mortality difference and that adding surgeons alone will not close the gap.
"Simply adding a surgeon is not going to solve everything. We need to address the whole access-to-care issue," he said. "Access to surgical care is not just about having an excellent hospital. It's about whether patients can reach those services in a timely manner when they need it. Where someone lives should not determine the opportunity to timely, high-quality care."
The authors note limitations: the study design cannot establish that the individuals who died were those who lacked a local surgeon, the CMS roster may misclassify surgeons who cover multiple counties or practice on a county border, and distance or travel time to the nearest surgeon could not be computed.
Co-authors include Faisal S. Jehan, MD, FSSO; Brian C. Longbottom, MD; Keely Kringlen, MD, MPH; and Sean Y. Kim, BS. The authors have no relevant financial conflicts to disclose.
Citation: Jehan FS, Longbottom BC, Kringlen K, et al. Gastrointestinal and Hepatopancreatobiliary Cancer Surgical Deserts and Population Cancer Mortality: A National County-Level Analysis. Journal of the American College of Surgeons. 2026.
#
About the American College of Surgeons
The American College of Surgeons (ACS) is a scientific and educational organization of surgeons founded in 1913 to raise the standards of surgical practice and improve the quality of care for all surgical patients. The ACS is dedicated to the ethical and competent practice of surgery. Its achievements have significantly influenced the course of scientific surgery in America and established it as an important advocate for all surgical patients. The ACS has more than 95,000 members and is the largest organization of surgeons in the world. "FACS" designates that a surgeon is a Fellow of the ACS.