Fossil Reefs May Reveal Where Caribbean Corals Can Survive

University of Texas at Austin

The fossilized remains of ancient coral reef ecosystems can often be found mere meters from where modern corals live today. In the Caribbean, where coral reefs have faced serious decline over the past 70 years, they can also serve as a window to a time when coral ecosystems were thriving.

Researchers at The University of Texas at Austin are bringing this paleontological perspective to modern coral conservation efforts. In two new papers, they highlight which coral species were most abundant in ancient Caribbean reefs at sites in northeastern Jamaica and suggest how this information could help guide reef rehabilitation today and in the future.

"Because we were studying already damaged reefs [in the modern-day Caribbean], we had a limited baseline of what a healthy reef used to look like and were missing understandings of things like resilience," said Claire Williams, who led research on the fossil and modern reefs while earning a doctorate at the UT Jackson School of Geosciences. "So, my theory was that by bringing in the fossil record, we could get a richer picture of coral tolerances and make better predictions for the future."

The findings were recently published in PALAIOS and Conservation Biology . Williams, who is now a postdoctoral researcher at Georgia Institute of Technology and Texas A&M University, collaborated on the research with scientists from the Jackson School, The University of West Indies, the Alligator Head Foundation, and The University of New Mexico.

At two sites in Jamaica, the team analyzed the corals found in fossil reefs dating back to 130,000-125,000 years ago — the Late Pleistocene epoch — a time known for interglacial warming periods. According to Williams, these past warming periods are good analogs for what the planet is projected to experience in about 50 to 100 years.

The fossil reefs are now above sea level, so the researchers adapted a transect method used to monitor modern corals: Instead of swimming above the reefs, the researchers walked along them, photographing the fossils to estimate the number and distribution of corals in an area. They then compared this data from fossil reefs with coral species at modern sites.

At the modern sites, the researchers found that certain branching corals called Acropora — including Acropora palmata and Acropora cervicornis — which were abundant during the Pleistocene, are now largely dead and covered by algae. What's more, most remaining corals are Porites astreoides, a globular species that Williams said can recover quickly after disturbances. But it doesn't provide helpful reef structure.

"These big branching species provide a lot of habitat and offshore protection. With that gone, we've lost that function on the reef," said Williams.

The solution to rebuilding the reef isn't as simple as planting more Acropora corals in degraded reef environments, said co-author Rowan Martindale, an associate professor at the Jackson School's Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences.

"We can nurture and transplant new, healthy corals from nurseries to damaged reefs, often referred to as coral gardening, but if they are in a place that's too hot in the future, they're not going to survive" Martindale said. "Many of the Alligator Head Foundation's transplanted corals died off during the heat-induced bleaching event in the summer of 2023."

With that in mind, the researchers also conducted a study on the ecological niches of ancient corals, analyzing the water temperature and salinity they can tolerate. In this analysis, they included data from mid-Holocene fossil records to get data points from a more recent period, 5,000–7,000 years ago. This data was then used to predict the places with similar ecological niches as these past environments – helping to indicate where the species might survive in the future.

The researchers also incorporated data from climate models to identify reef areas in the Caribbean that are projected to have the salinity and sea-surface temperature best-suited for species that can help foster and grow healthy reef ecosystems in the future. The best spots for conservation include parts of the Northern Caribbean, the Florida Keys and Yucatan Peninsula.

However, Williams said that their findings should be thought of as a starting point. Environments need to be consistently monitored and assessed for issues that can interfere with coral survival, such as disease, pollution, natural disasters and other environmental issues.

"The fossil record can improve our predictions and provide best-case ideas of where things might be able to survive," Williams said. "Conservation needs to be adaptive and to keep learning new information."

Martindale added that protecting reef ecosystems is critical for human communities who depend on them.

"There are people that need the reefs for fish and protection from hurricanes. You can't just abandon the places that rely on those functions," she said.

The research was funded by the National Science Foundation and The University of Texas Program in British, Irish and Empire Studies.

/Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.