Insects can convert food waste into animal feed, but animal proteins in these waste streams may pose a risk of transmitting bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE), also known as mad cow disease. Wageningen researchers have calculated that this risk is very low, offering new opportunities for circular animal feed production.
Insects can convert food waste and by-products from the food industry (such as unsold ready meals or slaughter by-products) into ingredients for animal feed. In this way, they can contribute to the transition towards a circular food production system, in which what would otherwise be wasted is reused. However, these waste streams may contain animal proteins that pose a risk of transmitting diseases such as bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE), also known as mad cow disease. For this reason, rearing insects on waste streams containing animal proteins is not permitted in the European Union.
Researchers from Wageningen Bioveterinary Research (WBVR) and Wageningen Food Safety Research (WFSR) investigated these risks. Their findings show that the risk of new BSE infections is very low under the current European control system.
Risks of different food waste streams investigated
To calculate the risk of BSE transmission through insect rearing, the researchers developed a mathematical model. They examined three types of waste streams: former foodstuffs from supermarkets, kitchen waste and processed animal material. They also looked at two insect species: mealworms and black soldier fly larvae.
In addition, they investigated how contaminated material could eventually reach cattle, for example through cross-contamination of animal feed or via grassland where manure is spread.
Very low risk, even under unfavourable conditions
In all scenarios investigated, the calculated risk of new BSE infections in cattle was very low, even under unfavourable conditions, such as accidentally feeding cattle pig feed containing insect meal.
However, certain conditions apply. In their model, the researchers assume that BSE prions cannot multiply in insects. "Furthermore, our model is based on three waste streams and two insect species. If other waste streams or insect species are used, the risk must therefore be reassessed," explains WBVR researcher Clazien de Vos.
New opportunities for circular food production
The results provide new insights into how food waste streams can be safely used in insect rearing. They may contribute to future discussions on European regulations and the opportunities for circular animal feed production.
At the same time, the researchers emphasise the importance of investigating other animal disease risks, including African swine fever and foot-and-mouth disease.