Food deserts, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture, are low-income neighborhoods where residents have limited access to healthy and affordable food. Opening a grocery store is a commonly proposed solution to improve food access in these areas, but that doesn't necessarily mean residents will shop there.
A nationwide study by researchers at Binghamton University and the University of Connecticut reveals that residents of low-income areas account for less than 20% of visits to newly opened stores in food deserts. The findings suggest that simply adding new stores isn't an adequate solution to the food access crisis in low-income areas.
The study, published in the journal Applied Geography, is the result of a collaborative, multidisciplinary effort that includes Binghamton University Assistant Professor of Geography Congcong Miao ; UConn Associate Professor of Geography, Sustainability, Community and Urban Studies Xiang Chen; and UConn Associate Professor of Allied Health Sciences Ran Xu. Miao and Chen are geographers, while Xu is a biostatistician in public health.
"Since my PhD program, my research has focused on spatial data science and geospatial computational methods with applications in urban transportation, human mobility, and related issues such as spatial accessibility and health disparity," said Miao, who joined Binghamton this fall.
Measuring the impact of new stores
A series of government policy initiatives — including the 2014 Farm Bill — sought to address food insecurity by encouraging the establishment of grocery stores in food-desert areas. While smaller regional studies have sought to assess the success of these measures, this is the first to use large-scale human mobility data to evaluate their policy impact nationwide.
The researchers used a quasi-experimental design, which relies on existing data to identify the treatment and control groups: in this case, 112 low-income, low-access (LILA) areas with newly opened grocery stores and 336 comparable areas without new store openings. They then evaluated residents' grocery shopping trips before and after the new store opening, comparing changes between the two groups.
What they found: Visits to the new store peaked during their first month, then declined before stabilizing. Residents of local LILA areas constituted less than 20% of visits to these stores on average; most customers came from outside the identified food desert.
Why new stores aren't enough
"When people think about a food desert, it's just a low-income area that lacks a grocery store. So, the solution is to add a grocery store," Xu explained. "But our study shows that this just isn't the case. Even if you add a grocery store, people don't go there for various reasons."
The issue of healthy food access isn't merely geographic, Chen noted. For some residents, affordability remains an obstacle, while others may stick with their current food sources, such as convenience stores, out of dietary habit or cultural preference.
"Once we know there's no such effect, maybe we can think about redirecting our federal investment toward addressing structural barriers to food access, such as high food prices," Chen said.
While new stores aren't effective as a sole solution, they may be more effective when combined with other strategies as part of a comprehensive approach, Miao said. And new stores may bring other benefits to a neighborhood besides food access, she said.
"Improving food access requires more than simply increasing the number of grocery stores," Miao said. "Policymakers also need to understand residents' needs, preferences, and everyday shopping behaviors — for example, by helping people better understand what a healthy diet looks like and making healthy food more affordable."
About Binghamton University
Binghamton University is a nationally ranked public research university and one of four university centers in the State University of New York (SUNY) system. Founded in 1946 and located in Vestal, N.Y., Binghamton is an R1 research institution, tackling complex challenges and driving innovation in areas that shape our world – from next-generation energy storage to responsible AI. Binghamton enrolls more than 18,000 students in 130+ majors across six schools, providing clear pathways for undergraduate students to future careers, supporting graduate students as they advance boundaries of innovation and discovery, and building partnerships that serve the public good from Binghamton to the rest of the world.