Brain and Heart Studies Rarely Use Music We Actually Listen To

UOW research finds we are only beginning to understand how the brain and heart respond to music, and the everyday listening experience is barely represented

We all know the joy of hearing a song we love. It can be a physical experience, as we tap our toes or sing at the top of our lungs. Or it can be emotional, lifting our mood or conjuring long-buried memories.

But new research from the University of Wollongong (UOW) has revealed that science has barely scratched the surface of how the brain and heart respond together. And it has overlooked the music most people listen to every day – pop.

UOW School of Psychology PhD candidate Scott Leimroth, undertook a review to discover how many studies had examined how our brains and hearts respond to music. He searched more than a thousand papers across five research databases for studies that recorded brain activity, using an electroencephalogram (EEG), and heart activity, using electrocardiogram (ECG), of healthy adults as they passively listened to music.

Mr Leimroth found just 18 studies, 10 of which used classical music as the benchmark. Not one focused on pop, revealing a gap in scientists' understanding of the everyday listening experience.

"Music is part of nearly everyone's life. We use it to manage our moods, to feel connected to others, to make sense of our emotions, for a spark of joy or nostalgia," Mr Leimroth said.

"But this reaction is hard to measure. Everyone responds differently and our response to a song can change from one day to the next, depending on mood, memory and attention. Brain activity and heart activity, when observed separately, each tell only part of the story."

The review found evidence that music has measurable effects on both the brain and heart. However, the how and why remain unclear. Most studies analysed brain and heart responses separately, leaving more questions than answers.

The studies also measured and reported results so differently they can't be compared. The few that analysed brain and heart together showed early signs that the two fall more into step while we listen to music.

Heart rate rose in some studies, fell in others and didn't change in several. Brain effects were spread across different types of activity with little overlap, although alpha activity, linked to relaxed alertness, came up most often.

"EEG captures the brain's response to a piece of music as it unfolds, millisecond by millisecond. ECG captures what the heart does at the same time. But observed on their own, each signal is ambiguous," Mr Leimroth said.

"A change in brain activity might be the music and a change in heart rate might be emotion or just breathing or posture. Recorded together, one can be checked against the other."

A former professional musician, Mr Leimroth said the review revealed an opportunity to deepen our understanding of how people connect with music.

"I was a musician long before I was a scientist, so the question of what music does to the body has been with me for most of my life."

About the research

'Exploring EEG and ECG in music listening: A scoping review', by Scott Leimroth, Robert Barry, Frances M De Blasio, and Timothy Byron, was published in Psychophysiology: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/psyp.70385

/Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.