Illinois Study Tests Soybean Varieties Against Dicamba Drift

College of ACES at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign

URBANA, Ill. — Some soybean growers who plant genetically modified dicamba-resistant soybeans have no intention of spraying the herbicide. Among other reasons, they're hedging against damaging dicamba exposure arising from neighboring fields. Now, a team from the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign has tested and confirmed conventionally bred soybean lines that tolerate dicamba exposure without damage. These traits could one day offer an alternative for growers who wish to grow conventional beans where dicamba drift occurs.

"Growers don't want chemicals trespassing on their farm and ruining their soybean crop," said study co-author Dean Riechers , professor in the Department of Crop Sciences , part of the College of Agricultural, Consumer and Environmental Sciences at U. of I.

Until more effective strategies are developed to avoid or prevent dicamba drift, the researchers say exposure-tolerant soybean lines may be a solution.

Riechers and his collaborators set out to replicate a natural experiment that had occurred years earlier — under non-controlled conditions — at a University of Missouri field station in the bootheel of Missouri, at the far southeastern corner of the state.

"They grow cotton and soybeans in that region, and dicamba exposure is a huge problem for them. When we visited, any non-dicamba resistant soybeans were very stunted. This was happening year after year, which allowed the breeders there to select for tolerance to dicamba," said study co-author Brian Diers , emeritus professor in crop sciences at U. of I.

But that wasn't the original aim of their breeding program. Caio Vieira , now an assistant professor and soybean breeder at the University of Arkansas , was at Missouri at the time. He and the late professor Pengyin Chen were growing multiple soybean lines when the experiment was serendipitously hit with dicamba from off-target sources, often in repeat succession.

"Back in 2019, we observed different responses of soybean genotypes within the same genetic family. That provided us with strong evidence that this trait could be genetically regulated," Vieira said. "We then screened diverse soybean accessions to confirm these observations, and later developed mapping genetic populations to narrow down the genetics behind off-target dicamba tolerance. This was an exciting project because it was the first to investigate this response as a genetic trait. Everything from field protocols to genetic materials had to be developed from scratch."

Although certain soybean lines looked promising in Missouri, the experiment couldn't be precisely replicated because neither the dosage nor the timing of dicamba exposure were known. To identify the level and frequency of dicamba drift at which sensitive and tolerant lines diverged, a controlled experiment was necessary. But, given the amount of ambient dicamba in Missouri's bootheel, the experiment had to be done somewhere else.

Vieira teamed up with Diers and Riechers, along with Seda Özer, who was a graduate student working on a doctorate with Diers at U. of I. at the time. Working at the Crop Sciences Research and Education Center in Urbana meant the team could plant tolerant and sensitive soybean lines and be assured that the only dicamba to affect the plants was applied by the researchers themselves.

Özer, now head of the Plant Breeding and Genetics Department at the Oil Seeds Research Institute in Osmaniye, Türkiye, explained, "We started with greenhouse experiments to see how much dicamba exposure was needed to distinguish tolerant and sensitive soybean lines. We then moved to field trials, testing different doses and repeated applications to better reflect what was happening in Missouri, where dicamba exposure wasn't always a one-time event."

The researchers knew that some soybean lines were naturally more tolerant to dicamba than others, and they wanted to find better ways to capture those differences.

"We hadn't originally planned to use drones, but the idea of detecting these differences from the air came up during conversations with our co-author Alper Adak, who also helped us process and analyze the images," Özer said.

The experiment revealed that low doses — one five-hundredths of the labeled dicamba rate — reliably separated tolerant and sensitive plants, and that repeated doses at this rate caused long-lasting damage in sensitive lines, much like real-world drift. The study's drones captured damage over time, similar to a previous ACES study that showed damage to sensitive soybean lines can be detected from the air at one ten-thousandth of the labeled rate for dicamba.

"We weren't just trying to detect the damage in this study. We wanted to find the level that separates the tolerant and sensitive lines," Riechers said. "The goal here was to see if we could repeat what researchers in Missouri found, then make lemonade out of lemons — when you know you might have to deal with off-target exposure, you want something that can at least tolerate it."

Riechers notes that the tolerant lines can only handle levels representative of off-target exposure, not a full dicamba application at the labeled rate. The researchers also weren't able to bring plants bred for southern Missouri to maturity in Central Illinois, so it's not clear if the tolerance trait may come with yield penalties or, on the positive side, whether the trait may also confer tolerance to other herbicides, diseases, or various environmental stressors. The team aims to find out through follow-up studies, and are even looking to move the trait into edamame and other specialty soybeans.

"The goal of this trait is not to spray dicamba on top of non-dicamba-resistant soybeans, but rather to allow non-dicamba-resistant plants to coexist along with cropping systems that include dicamba," Vieira said. "This is important to diversify herbicide-based cropping systems, as well as support the expansion of non-GMO soybean acreage for food-grade and specialty markets."

The study, "Unmanned aerial vehicle time-series phenotyping illuminates genotype-specific responses to off-target dicamba exposure in soybean," is published in The Plant Phenome Journal [DOI: 10.1002/ppj2.70118 ]. Authors include Seda Özer, Brian Diers, Dean Riechers, Caio Vieira, and Alper Adak.

Research in the College of ACES is made possible in part by Hatch funding from USDA's National Institute of Food and Agriculture. This study was also supported by the Mid-South Soybean Board (grant 20-455-23) and the United Soybean Board (grant 2120-172-0147).

/Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.