Babies Rarely See Exaggerated Faces Used in Emotion Research, Study Finds

University of Kansas

LAWRENCE — A new paper in Communications Psychology calls into question the value of exaggerated facial expressions commonly used in research to study babies' emotional understanding. The study, led by University of Kansas researchers, shows that babies ages 6-17 months rarely encounter these expressions in everyday life — and rarely see full faces at all.

"Basic emotion theory posits that specific facial configurations were evolutionarily conserved as ways of communicating particular emotion-relevant signals among humans, among conspecifics," said lead author Katie Hoemann, assistant professor of psychology at KU. "In all these studies, and you see it all over the place, happiness means a big toothy smile. Anger means a big scowl. Sadness means a super exaggerated frown. And these are the kinds of stimuli that are used in tests of emotion perception for people of all age groups, for the most part."

The work stems from a running collaboration between researchers at KU, Rutgers University and other institutions. Jeffrey Girard, associate professor of psychology at KU, co-led the study. Much of the data Hoemann and Girard analyzed was collected, prepared and coded at Rutgers.

Hoemann and her co-authors wondered how often babies see these exaggerated facial configurations in real life. They analyzed an existing dataset of monthly, hourlong home recordings of infants ages 6 months to 17 months, categorizing their exposures to faces and facial expressions.

"When we looked for exact matches to facial configurations that have been hypothesized to be evolutionarily conserved, universal expressions of particular emotions, we found that it was really rare," Hoemann said. "Happiness was relatively the most common. But even if we look at the share of all full-face time — any moment an infant was seeing a full face — it's still only 12% of the time."

Even when researchers considered only the time babies spent seeing full faces, the exaggerated expressions were rare.

While traditional research into emotional development often depends on a set of facial configurations associated with particular emotions, the KU-led study found that real-world faces are much more varied in expression, and the same facial configurations can signify different things in different settings.

"The same collection of facial movements that you would make can mean different things in different contexts," Hoemann said. "But also, in relation to the same context — like being happy or angry — you can make lots of different combinations of facial movements. That, combined with the theoretical frameworks we're thinking of, which look at how infants use information from their environment broadly to learn everything they know, not just about emotions, prompted us to look at what's actually going on. What's their information ecology like? What are they exposed to? The next steps would be to ask how they might leverage that to learn what they ultimately do."

The findings suggest that babies' understanding of emotion develops through a much broader and more complex set of factors and interactions than simplified facial expressions can capture. Hoemann said researchers should design studies that account for a wider range of information than facial expressions alone.

"A kind of distilled version of the prior literature has assumed that these must be reliable and prevalent signals in everyday life," Hoemann said. "But if we see that they're not, it suggests that infants are doing something else. They're gathering information from other pieces, or they're engaging in other types of learning processes in order to eventually become emotionally functional culture members. Clearly, infants and children are doing it, but the question is: What pieces are they leveraging to be able to do that?"

Even when babies encounter faces that match the configurations used in research, in whole or in part, those expressions appear within complex emotional contexts that change moment to moment. Facial expressions combine with words, gestures, movement, touch and other sensory information to convey emotional meaning.

"It's not that they never happen, but they're not capturing all of this beautiful heterogeneity that is really out there," Hoemann said. "Instead, we should think about the process of emotion and the process of learning emotion as deeply contextually embedded. What do these facial movements mean in this moment to these people, in combination with all these other things that are going on?"

Hoemann's current research examines how infants' exposure to facial movements relates to the language they hear from caregivers.

"We're looking at how this intersects with the language that infants were hearing from their caregivers during these interactions. Specifically, we're looking at the presence of emotion-related words, namely emotion labels or clear references to emotion, like 'gross' or 'yucky,'" she said. "We're looking to see whether, for example, infants might be latching onto emotion words as particularly salient cues in their environment to kind of tag those moments. These kinds of properties of associative and integrative learning have been widely shown to drive learning in general, and also for infants. We're really applying these principles now to looking at emotion-relevant information."

Hoemann and Girard's co-authors were Marissa Ogren, Lauren Leotti and Vanessa LoBue of Rutgers University; Lisa Feldman Barrett of Northeastern University and Massachusetts General Hospital; and Lisa Oakes of the University of California, Davis. Current work examining language is led by Shannon Brady of Rutgers University.

Hoemann said her findings suggest that babies' understanding of emotion develops through a much richer array of everyday interactions than simplified facial expressions alone can convey. While it's fun to mug for babies, caregivers should recognize that emotional learning happens in a much broader context.

"When we see these emotion-literacy posters, where people are smiling, and people are scowling, realize that those aren't representative of what's going on in our everyday lives," Hoemann said.

/Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.