Heart study debunks meat metabolite myth

A metabolite linked to red meat and egg-rich diets is not the heart attack and stroke trigger many feared, new Australian research reveals.

A study by Heart Research Institute in Sydney has debunked the widely publicised belief that trimethylamine-N-oxide, or TMAO, can clog up arteries, causing catastrophic heart problems like heart attacks and strokes. “We’ve discovered that contrary to other research, this metabolite called TMAO, isn’t actually responsible for these common debilitating heart conditions,” says Assoc Prof John O’Sullivan, head of the HRI’s Cardiometabolic Disease Group.

The study is published in the European Society of Cardiology journal Cardiovascular Research.

Heart disease is a leading cause of death in Australia, with more the 1.2 million people currently living with one of more conditions related to heart or vascular disease, including stroke. In recent years, scientific studies have warned of the heart attack and stroke risk posed by trimethylamine-N-oxide, or TMAO, a metabolite generated from choline, a nutrient abundant in red meat- and egg-rich diets. “It has been proposed that high circulating levels of TMAO leads to thickened arteries, sticky blood, heart attack, and stroke,” explains Assoc Prof O’Sullivan. “But the scientific literature has not been able to replicate the original studies, and there have been many conflicting reports.”

The HRI-led team set out to clarify TMAO’s relationship to health and disease. They studied the gut microbiome of mice with a healthy diet and a diet rich in choline, the red meat nutrient that makes TMAO. Crucially they found that TMAO was increased in both healthy (with healthy arteries) and unhealthy diets. The mechanism by which TMAO increased was different in the two groups. An analysis in a large human cohort also found no causal link between TMAO levels and atherosclerosis, or thickening arteries.

“Essentially, we found no direct link between TMAO and the extent of atherosclerosis either in humans or in the laboratory,” Assoc Prof O’Sullivan explains.

“This showed TMAO is not the bad guy of heart attacks and stroke that we’d previously thought.”

The paper, entitled “Plasma Levels of TMAO can be Increased with ‘Healthy’ and ‘Unhealthy’ Diets and Do Not Correlate with the Extent of Atherosclerosis but with Plaque Instability,” is available here.

/Public Release. The material in this public release comes from the originating organization and may be of a point-in-time nature, edited for clarity, style and length. View in full here.