Scientists have hypothesized that, in the fraction of a second following the Big Bang, minute black holes may have been forged within tiny, dense pockets that collapsed under their own gravity. If these primordial black holes are ever found, they could represent a significant component of dark matter - the invisible substance that makes up most of the universe's matter.
Now physicists at MIT and elsewhere have worked out a way that astronomers could detect a primordial black hole. The team carried out theoretical calculations and three-dimensional simulations to show what would happen if a lingering primordial black hole were captured by a modern, sun-like star.
In a study appearing today in the Astrophysical Journal , the team's simulations reveal a dramatic evolution: When an atom-sized primordial black hole with the mass of an asteroid is caught up in the gravity of a sun-sized star, it should quickly fall into the star's core. Then, it would begin to devour the star from the inside.
If the star spins sufficiently fast, the simulations show that a disk of its own stardust should begin to circle as it falls into the black hole.
"Once the disk forms, this is essentially a death sentence for the star," says lead author Ore Gottlieb, an assistant professor of physics at MIT.
Within a matter of seconds, interactions between the black hole and the spinning disk should launch powerful jets of matter that ultimately pierce through the star, making it explode.
That dramatic fate, the researchers calculated, would generate a flash of blue and ultraviolet light, along with gamma- and X-rays. This flash should be bright enough to detect with current telescopes.
"There is hope for us to probe primordial black holes through interactions with stars," Gottlieb says. "We expect this to be visible, and it's something we should look into."
The study's co-authors are Matteo Cantiello of the Flatiron Institute, Cameron Norton and Matthew Kleban of New York University, and Ken Van Tilburg of Stanford University.
Quantum quarry
Today, the smallest and lightest primordial black holes would have evaporated away due to Hawking radiation - a quantum effect that was proposed by the physicist Stephen Hawking to describe how black holes can radiate energy and shrink, very slowly, over cosmic time.
Larger, heavier primordial black holes, however, should still be around, not having had quite enough time to disappear. These lingering relics would be about the size of an atom, and as massive as an asteroid (or about a millionth of the mass of the Earth). Gottlieb and his colleagues wondered: If asteroid-mass primordial black holes indeed exist, how might they interact with stars today? What's more, could this interaction be a way to detect primordial black holes, and confirm their existence?
In their new study, the researchers carried out analytic calculations and numerical simulations based on equations of general relativity, hydrodynamics, stellar evolution, and particle physics, to determine how an asteroid-mass primordial black hole could be captured by a star and what events might unfold from there.
They discovered that the gravitational pull from a single star would not be enough to trap a passing primordial black hole. However, the researchers found that gravitational interaction with a companion, such as a second star or planet, could efficiently trap a primordial black hole.
In this three-body configuration, the team calculated the friction that the black hole would experience as it passes through the stellar material. They found that repeated passages could gradually shrink its orbit, and over a span of thousands to millions of years - nearly instantaneous on cosmic timescales - the black hole would fall into the center of the star.
"Then, this is where the action begins," Gottlieb says.
A critical pull
The team modeled the black hole evolution within the star. How quickly the black hole grows depends on how much energy the black hole releases back into the surrounding star as it heats the gas and slows further infall.
They found that most of the energy is carried into the black hole, allowing the black hole to grow faster than previously thought. Within several million years, the black hole would have consumed about 1 percent of the star's mass. If at this critical point, the star spins fast enough, its gas can no longer fall directly into the black hole and instead piles up in a rotating disk of material around a few-meter-sized black hole at the heart of the star.
"Inside the star, you have a black hole with a disk," Gottlieb says. "The black hole is also spinning, and it's twisting space and time."
As the black hole continues to consume the disk's spiraling material, it twists and pulls on the disk's magnetic field.
This simulation depicts the moments after a primordial black hole is captured by a star. As soon as the black hole falls into the star's center, it creates a swirling disk of material (orange). Within a matter of seconds, interactions between the black hole and the spinning disk should launch powerful jets of matter that ultimately pierce through the star, making it explode.
"This twisted magnetic field will power very strong electromagnetic jets from the poles of the black hole," Gottlieb explains. "And these jets will just explode the star, within a few dozen seconds. It's very fast. Once you have a disk, you are done."
Finally, the team estimated the color and intensity of light that such an explosion could generate, from start to finish, across the electromagnetic spectrum.
"We would initially detect some X-rays and gamma rays, then over time optical and infrared emissions, and later on radio emissions," Gottlieb says. "This is something we could potentially detect, if it's not happening too far from us. It could be many galaxies away, not just in our backyard."
He points out that other astrophysical phenomena could produce a similar flash. If astronomers detect such a flash, they will have to combine the signal with other clues to confirm that the source is a primordial black hole.
"For instance, if the star is a certain mass that is not supposed to explode, it must be something that is happening inside that is a sort of parasite that is consuming the star from the inside," Gottlieb says. "The broader impact is that we can now place constraints on primordial black holes, and their contributions to dark matter, using observations."
This work was supported, in part, by the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science Advanced Scientific Computing Research Program, and by the National Science Foundation.