PAC-MAN Capsules Gobble Particles in Turbulent Water

New York University

Scientists have created hollow capsules with single openings that can selectively filter particles thanks to the turbulence in surrounding waters—at times, ingesting particles like PAC-MAN eating up dots.

These capsules—which rely on geometry and turbulence to take in or expel particles rather than chemistry—can be customized in a range of sizes that could be leveraged for cleaning up water or for targeted drug delivery, according to the research published in Science .

Turbulence is characterized by irregular, chaotic movement of liquid or gas that occurs at all different scales, from cream swirling into a cup of coffee to whirlpools that form at river rapids.

"Turbulence is usually thought of as pure chaos: it mixes, scatters, and wastes energy. We asked whether that chaos could be put to work," said Stefano Sacanna, professor of chemistry at New York University, who co-led the research with William Irvine, professor of physics at the University of Chicago.

Calm vs. chaos

The researchers hypothesized that they could harness the energy of turbulence using structures that separate the chaos from a quieter environment. To do so, they fabricated hollow polymer capsules, each with a single hole, and placed the capsules in liquid that was stirred or shaken to create turbulence. The capsule walls shielded the interior from the swirling flow, creating a safe harbor that the researchers dubbed a "turbulence shelter." Only swirls smaller than the hole can get in, so the inside stays calm while the outside churns.

When the researchers added small particles to the turbulent water, the asymmetry in these two environments—the calm pocket surrounded by chaos—turned the opening in the capsule into a selective gate that allowed certain particles to enter or exit, depending on the turbulent flow and the size of the hole.

"Inside the capsule, it's fairly calm. But outside, the environment is raging," explained Irvine. "This creates a gradient, so particles flow, and functions emerge."

"The shells don't fill up randomly. Depending on how well a particle fits the hole, a shell either gobbles particles up until it is packed full, or keeps them out almost completely," added Sacanna. "Because the hungry ones look like little PAC-MANs, we call this the PAC-MAN effect."

When the researchers adjusted the size of the hole in a capsule to make it larger or smaller, it altered the amount of turbulence that could enter the shelter, and as a result, the particles that were allowed in or out.

"This selectivity doesn't require chemistry, and the capsule is not a sieve. Particles that would slip easily through the hole can be kept out, while ones that barely fit get packed in. The capsule reshapes the turbulence at its opening, and that decides which particles end up inside," said Sacanna.

From small to much, much smaller

Would the selective filtration work just as well with a pea-sized capsule and a microscopic one smaller than a red blood cell? To test this, the researchers replicated the experiment with hollow capsules at three different scales: one centimeter, one millimeter, and five micrometers. The centimeter and millimeter capsules were fabricated at the University of Chicago using specialized 3D printers, while the smallest of capsules were created using synthetic methods in Sacanna's lab.

When the capsules were submerged in turbulent water, they all took in or dispensed particles relative to the size of the capsule's hole.

"This PAC-MAN effect manifests in all three systems, spanning from microscopic to macroscopic scales—the same simple design works throughout," said Sacanna.

Adjusting the geometry of all three capsules—both the size of the opening and the thickness of the shell—allowed the researchers to "tune" the system to filter in or out different sized particles. With centimeter-sized shells, changing the hole size by less than 10 percent was enough to switch a shell from collecting particles to rejecting them. And in much smaller capsules, the shells could tell particles apart by size or density, taking in only certain ones.

Custom solutions for water filtration, drug delivery

The capsules' ability to accumulate particles or release them, depending on their geometry, opens up possibilities for filtering fluids and sorting particles. This could be useful for environmental cleanup, when certain contaminants need to be removed from water. And because the capsules can be tuned to release their cargo—including at specific rates, ranging from seconds to years—the researchers see the potential of using this system for drug delivery.

More broadly, the researchers now know how to put the chaos of turbulence to good use.

"This gives us a new way of thinking about filtration: instead of spending energy to control a flow, you let the energy already present in turbulence do the work," Sacanna said.

"Normally, to move, you must expend energy—a bird must flap its wings or a fish move its tail," added Irvine. "But here, by engineering a specific particle shape, we can leverage the ambient energy that is flowing around us all the time. You're essentially getting order out of chaos."

Additional study authors include Sarah Chong and Zhe Xu of NYU and Matteo Sabato, Yaocheng Li, Daqian Gao, and Martin Falk of the University of Chicago. This work was supported by the US Army Research Office (#W911NF-17-S-0002, #W911NF-18-1-0046, and #W911NF-20-1-0117), the Brown Foundation, Kairos Ventures, and the National Science Foundation (Award No. 2521852).

/Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.