‘Transformer’ pinwheels offer new twist on nano-engineered materials

University of Michigan

Producing chirality, a property found throughout nature, through large-scale self-assembly could lead to applications in sensing, machine perception and more


The illustration shows how the honeycomb structure reconfigures into a pinwheel structure. The ability to make these twisted structures at the nanoscale could have applications in sensing, machine vision and more. Image credit: S. Zhou et al, Nature, DOI: 10.1038/s41586-022-05384-8
The illustration shows how the honeycomb structure reconfigures into a pinwheel structure. The ability to make these twisted structures at the nanoscale could have applications in sensing, machine vision and more. Image credit: S. Zhou et al, Nature, DOI: 10.1038/s41586-022-05384-8

A newly discovered pinwheel structure-self-assembled from pyramid-shaped nanoparticles-may enable unique material properties that could be useful in areas like machine vision, armor, chemical and biological sensing, and more.

Study abstract: Chiral assemblies of pinwheel superlattices on substrates (DOI: 10.1038/s41586-022-05384-8)

The finding comes from a research collaboration led by the University of Illinois and the University of Michigan.

A key quality of the nanomaterial is chirality, a kind of twist found throughout nature from DNA’s double-helix to spiral galaxies. Nature uses chirality to reliably engineer very complex and dynamic systems, including all living organisms. Recreating these twisted structures on the nanoscale hasn’t been easy, however. Researchers have relied on templates that produced very small structures, limiting their usefulness in the design of nano-engineered materials, said Qian Chen, professor of materials science and engineering at Illinois and co-corresponding author of the paper in Nature.

The team decided to explore the possibilities of pyramid-shaped particles as building blocks, which had previously been shown to arrange themselves into patterns that could change depending on their environments.


An electron microscope image shows the nanopyramids settled into a pinwheel pattern.  The ability to make these twisted structures at the nanoscale could have applications in sensing, machine vision and more. Image credit: S. Zhou et al, Nature, DOI: 10.1038/s41586-022-05384-8
An electron microscope image shows the nanopyramids settled into a pinwheel pattern. The ability to make these twisted structures at the nanoscale could have applications in sensing, machine vision and more. Image credit: S. Zhou et al, Nature, DOI: 10.1038/s41586-022-05384-8

Using graph theory, Michigan’s Nicholas Kotov, the Irving Langmuir Professor of Chemical Sciences and Engineering and co-corresponding author of the paper, and Jun Lu and Ji-Young Kim, U-M postdoctoral researchers in chemical engineering, predicted that complex structures can emerge-just like in living systems-when the arrangements of these particles are chiral.

“It is amazing to observe how tight the relationship between chirality and practicality is,” Kotov said. “As soon as the particle layer becomes chiral, it acquires new useful properties.”

Chen and her group then made the structures out of gold nanoparticles, enabling them to self-assemble while floating in a tiny droplet of a water-based solution that sat atop a silicon wafer. As the fluid dried, the pyramids self-assembled onto the flat surface.

If the particles have no electric charge, they form a honeycomb pattern that isn’t chiral. But electric charges make the tiny pyramids turn a little with respect to one another, twisting the honeycomb into a repeating pinwheel structure.

“The resulting lattice is large enough to be seen with the naked eye,” said former Illinois postdoctoral researcher Shan Zhou, the first author of the study and now an assistant professor of nanoscience and biomedical engineering at South Dakota School of Mines and Technology.

While the lattice may be visible with the naked eye, the assembly of pyramids with 100-nanometer sides was not-Chen had an electron microscope set up to peer into the droplets. In fact, that feedback enabled the team to adjust the electric charge to get the pinwheel pattern.


As the droplet dries, the nanoparticles settle into pinwheel patterns. The ability to make these twisted structures at the nanoscale could have applications in sensing, machine vision and more. Image credit: S. Zhou et al, Nature, DOI: 10.1038/s41586-022-05384-8
As the droplet dries, the nanoparticles settle into pinwheel patterns. The ability to make these twisted structures at the nanoscale could have applications in sensing, machine vision and more. Image credit: S. Zhou et al, Nature, DOI: 10.1038/s41586-022-05384-8

“The liquid-phase electron microscopy allowed us to take the superlattice assembly even further,” Chen said.

Measuring how the twist on those pinwheels could affect light wasn’t possible in an ordinary lab, though. The trouble is, the pinwheel pattern isn’t one continuous design-it is broken into smaller domains like neighborhoods on a city map. These were equally divided between a right-hand twist and a left-hand twist. Shine light through it, and it doesn’t get the strong twist it would get if all the pinwheels pointed in the same direction. With domains 0.005 millimeters across, even a laser wasn’t small enough to focus on a single one.

“The biggest challenge is to characterize and understand the chirality of the superlattices,” Lu said.

The team had to take their pinwheel samples to Argonne National Laboratory to be measured with a laser and an electron microscope. The laser provided twisted light that was tightly focused on a few domains, and the domains that matched the twist were essentially lit up when viewed with an ultrafast electron microscope.


Colorized electron microscope images (blue and orange) alongside the X-ray diffraction pattern reveals the pinwheel structure. The ability to make these twisted structures at the nanoscale could have applications in sensing, machine vision and more. Image credit: S. Zhou et al, Nature, DOI: 10.1038/s41586-022-05384-8
Colorized electron microscope images (blue and orange) alongside the X-ray diffraction pattern reveals the pinwheel structure. The ability to make these twisted structures at the nanoscale could have applications in sensing, machine vision and more. Image credit: S. Zhou et al, Nature, DOI: 10.1038/s41586-022-05384-8

“No one has been able to directly see the chiral responses of objects at such a small length using other techniques,” said Haihua Liu, a researcher at Argonne’s Center for Nanoscale Materials, who helped measure the chirality of the pinwheel lattices.

Future work on the structures will explore how to achieve lattices that twist in only one direction and then translate these chiral assemblies into a range of applications. Kotov suggests biosensors for viruses and “smart,” adaptable catalysts that take advantage of the quick shift from the honeycomb to the pinwheel structure.

This dynamic reconfiguration could also be useful for machine vision such as LiDAR on self-driving cars, which relies on twisted light to achieve depth perception. Study co-author Kai Sun, U-M associate professor of physics, said that the pinwheel lattices are potentially useful in the design of combat helmets and airplanes, for example.

“The interesting behaviors of pinwheel lattice can go beyond their chiroptical responses,” said Alex Travesset, a professor at Iowa State University who performed the geometric calculations for the pinwheel lattice.

The Office of Naval Research supported this research through a Multidisciplinary University Research Initiative.

Kotov is also the Joseph B. and Florence V. Cejka Professor of Chemical Engineering, a professor of material science and engineering and macromolecular science and engineering.

/Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) may be of a point-in-time nature, edited for clarity, style and length. The views and opinions expressed are those of the author(s).View in full here.