The holiday season is a time for gatherings with family and friends—as well as for less festive, but necessary, duties: organizing, preparing for, and cleaning up after these gatherings. These are examples of service tasks that, according to previous research, women and girls are expected to fill.
While such stereotypical assumptions have been studied among adults in the past, it is not known when in life they begin. A new study by a team of psychology researchers addresses this question.
Its findings , which appear in the journal Developmental Science, show that both men and women, as well as boys and girls from the ages of five to eight, expect girls to perform certain types of service tasks—those that help a larger group, but that come at a personal cost to the helper, such as the opportunity to do something more enjoyable.
But there are some differences in these expectations. The study shows that girls and women expect girls to help more than boys regardless of the nature of the task. However, it also shows that boys and men expect girls to help more than boys only when that help is a costly service. By contrast, when tasks are seen as non-costly—those that don't deprive the helper of another opportunity, such as playing with friends—boys and men do not hold these gendered expectations.
"While girls and women expected girls to help more than boys overall, boys and men expected girls to help more than boys only when that help was a costly service," says lead author Sophie Arnold, a postdoctoral researcher at Princeton University and an NYU doctoral student when the study was conducted. "These findings offer new perspectives on the origins of service disparities observed between adult men and women in work and at home."
"While gendered expectations are not uniform, they are nonetheless present among children as young as five," observes Andrei Cimpian, a psychology professor at New York University and the paper's senior author. "With a better understanding of where these expectations begin, we can begin to unpack how they relate to the disparities we see among adults."
How the Study Was Conducted
In the study, which also included Katharina Block, a social psychologist at the University of Amsterdam who was an NYU postdoctoral researcher at the time of the study, the authors interviewed approximately 200 children, aged five to eight, and approximately 200 adults. Participants were asked about whether girls or boys would help in four different classroom settings across three types of scenarios: non-costly service, which benefits the group at no cost to the helper; costly service, which benefits the group at a cost to the helper; and interpersonal helping, which benefits a specific individual. Interpersonal helping might include helping another child who fell off the swings.
The study's participants were shown cartoon pictures of multiple boys and girls while being asked who would be the one to help—one of the pictured boys or one of the pictured girls—in different scenarios, such as this one:
One of these children said they would help set up the materials [costly: even though they wanted to play outside with their friends for recess / non-costly: since they didn't want to play outside for recess anyway]. Which of these children said they would help set up the materials? One of the boys or one of the girls?
What the Study Found
The results showed that both children and adults expected girls to do more costly service than boys. Moreover, in these interviews, girls and women expected girls to help more than boys overall—across the costly service, non-costly service, and interpersonal helping scenarios. By contrast, boys and men expected girls to help more than boys only when that help was a costly service—their expectations about interpersonal helping and non-costly service were neutral.
"These findings suggest that gendered expectations are strongest when helping demands personal sacrifice for a group or institution," explains Arnold. "These intensified expectations are already in place by ages five to eight, potentially representing one pathway through which gender disparities in service behavior develop over time."